← Intelligence

Weekly small experiment · 2026-W47

Checkpoint
or restart?

The urgent job is real. So is the half-finished work.

Give four policies the same action clock and the same urgent arrivals. Change interruption pressure, deadlines and the cost of saving a place. Completed value, missed urgency and discarded progress stay separate.

Loading the seeded interruption trace…

01 / policy

Finish first

Never interrupt an ordinary job.

— completed value

02 / policy

Drop and restart

Discard progress and start urgency now.

— completed value

03 / policy

Checkpoint and return

Pay to save progress, then resume it.

— completed value

04 / policy

Coin flip

A seeded random pre-emption baseline.

— completed value

Try this first

Make interruptions cheap. Then make saving expensive.

At the defaults, checkpoint-and-return averages 431.586 completed-value points across 128 seeds, versus 402.031 for drop-and-restart and 300.844 for finish-first. A free checkpoint rises to 449.773. At three save actions, it falls to 382.820 while drop-and-restart stays at 402.031.

Resumability is not free.

Every tick buys one action. Ordinary jobs take nine actions. Urgent jobs take three and expire after seven ticks. Finish-first protects current progress but misses more urgent work. Restart reacts immediately but throws away ordinary progress. Checkpoint preserves that progress after paying the selected save cost.

The coin-flip policy is a simple random baseline. No policy sees future arrivals. All four receive the same trace, values and deadlines for a seed.

Mean completed value · seeds 1–128
SettingFinishRestartCheckpointCoin flip
Default300.844402.031431.586386.164
25% storm434.906642.422639.984594.773
Free save300.844402.031449.773386.164
Three-action save300.844402.031382.820386.164
Long deadline431.805406.195439.883404.719

What the controls change

Seed
Replays urgent arrivals and random-policy choices.
Interruptions
Chance that one urgent job arrives on a tick.
Ordinary job
Actions required before ordinary value counts.
Urgent deadline
Ticks before an incomplete urgent job expires.
Save cost
Actions checkpoint-and-return spends before urgency begins.

Where the toy stops.

This is a deterministic single-desk queue, not an employee, language-model, biological, reliability or financial benchmark. Urgency labels are perfect; jobs have fixed work and fixed value; there is no learning, collaboration, rework, safety severity, money or human judgment.

All 1,152 matched worlds and 4,608 policy outcomes are retained across nine predeclared settings. No seed was removed. The empirical study is upcoming; this release reports scripted simulation results only.

Method & parameter guide ↓Source package ↓All batch results ↓Read the model

Previously: Work or Proof? · Explore the eight small worlds.