← Intelligence

Weekly small experiment · 2026-W46

Work
or proof?

A busy pipeline can make more work than it can honestly finish.

Give five teams the same action budget and the same hidden-quality candidate stream. Only reviewed valid candidates count. Change review capacity, expiry and queue size; keep blocked, expired and idle work visible.

Loading the seeded workflow…

01 / allocation policy

Six make, two check

Put 75% of every tick into producing candidates.

READY

02 / allocation policy

Four make, four check

Split the fixed action budget evenly.

READY

03 / allocation policy

Two make, six check

Keep six review actions even when the queue is empty.

READY

04 / allocation policy

Queue-aware

Make below a visible target; check at or above it.

READY

05 / allocation policy

Random split

Choose make or check from a seeded 50/50 draw.

READY

A queue bar shows produced candidates that have not crossed review. Candidate validity is hidden from every policy until review; the reader sees outcomes, not an oracle available to the policy.

Try this first

Triple review capacity. Keep the team.

Press Show outcome. Then let one review action inspect three candidates. The six-maker team changes from a clogged queue to the strongest fixed allocation. Restore one candidate per review and shrink the queue to 16. Activity stays high; accepted work does not.

Production is not completion.

Every tick contains eight make-or-check actions. Production places one candidate with hidden seeded validity into a first-in, first-out queue. Review perfectly accepts valid candidates and rejects invalid ones. Unreviewed candidates expire after the deadline. A full queue blocks production.

Every policy draws from the same candidate sequence and sees only its queue and past reviews. The queue-aware rule uses no quality oracle: it makes below a visible target and checks at or above it. Fixed policies produce first and review second within each tick.

The same accepted total can hide opposite failures.

Mean accepted valid candidates · seeds 1–64
Setting6 make / 2 check4 / 42 / 6Queue-awareRandom
Default167.250334.750167.500331.828317.031
Perfect quality240480240476454.828
35% valid83.734167.28184.625165.859158.391
Two per review334.734334.750167.500443.891333.063
Three per review503.234334.750167.500499333.516

In the default batch, six-makers average 346 expiries, 72 blocked production actions and 62 candidates still waiting. Two-makers accept nearly the same total but spend 480 review actions idle. Similar accepted totals conceal overload on one side and unused capacity on the other.

When one review action handles three candidates, six-makers accept 503.234 on average. The balance is conditional on review throughput—not a universal maker/checker ratio.

What the controls change

Seed
Replays candidate quality and random-policy actions.
Actions
Total production-or-review opportunities available to every policy per tick.
Candidate quality
Seeded probability a produced candidate is valid.
Review capacity
Oldest candidates inspected per review action.
Review deadline
Ticks an unreviewed candidate may wait before expiry.
Queue limit
Maximum unreviewed candidates retained.
Queue-aware target
Visible level where the adaptive policy switches from making to checking.

Where the toy stops.

This is a deterministic teaching world, not an employee or model productivity benchmark, quality-assurance prescription, agent-framework test, biological model or financial system. Candidate validity is a bit. Review is perfect and equally difficult for every candidate. Rework, correlated errors, reviewer mistakes, task heterogeneity, learning, safety severity, compute, money and human judgment are absent.

All 640 matched seeded worlds and 3,200 policy outcomes are retained across ten predeclared settings. No seed was removed. Accepted, rejected, expired, blocked, idle and queued outcomes remain separate. No private conversation text is included.

Method & parameter guide ↓Source package ↓All batch results ↓Read the model

Previously: Bridge or Bus? · Explore the eight small worlds.