{ "version": "1.1.0", "protocol": "Matched seeds 1–32. Defaults frozen before batch. All runs retained. Simulation only; no real-world calibration.", "id": "cell-city", "title": "The city of freeloaders", "metric": "cooperation", "arms": [ { "label": "Shared founders", "metric": "cooperation", "n": 32, "mean": 0.9423828124999999, "min": 0.8177083333333334, "p10": 0.828125, "median": 0.9791666666666666, "p90": 0.984375, "max": 0.9895833333333334 }, { "label": "Mixed founders", "metric": "cooperation", "n": 32, "mean": 0.03401692708333333, "min": 0.005208333333333333, "p10": 0.015625, "median": 0.03125, "p90": 0.052083333333333336, "max": 0.0625 } ], "pairedDifference": { "n": 32, "mean": -0.9083658854166666, "min": -0.9739583333333334, "p10": -0.9635416666666667, "median": -0.9322916666666666, "p90": -0.8385416666666666, "max": -0.796875 }, "runs": [ { "seed": 1, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.90625, "infrastructure": 0.9609381452384513, "output": 1.4500000000000002 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.036458333333333336, "infrastructure": 0.022043933933022005, "output": 0.05833333333333334 } } ] }, { "seed": 2, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.9895833333333334, "infrastructure": 0.9743126838558946, "output": 1.5833333333333335 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.015625, "infrastructure": 0.02484896761748403, "output": 0.025 } } ] }, { "seed": 3, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.984375, "infrastructure": 0.9390572704464856, "output": 1.5750000000000002 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.03125, "infrastructure": 0.029684430458269524, "output": 0.05 } } ] }, { "seed": 4, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.9895833333333334, "infrastructure": 0.9092691652021856, "output": 1.5833333333333335 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.026041666666666668, "infrastructure": 0.03929993661587101, "output": 0.04166666666666667 } } ] }, { "seed": 5, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.9739583333333334, "infrastructure": 0.9437210696621557, "output": 1.5583333333333336 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.026041666666666668, "infrastructure": 0.03138114751019815, "output": 0.04166666666666667 } } ] }, { "seed": 6, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.8177083333333334, "infrastructure": 0.9275046588114373, "output": 1.3083333333333336 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.015625, "infrastructure": 0.023734103876291785, "output": 0.025 } } ] }, { "seed": 7, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.8177083333333334, "infrastructure": 0.9255163424557605, "output": 1.3083333333333336 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.020833333333333332, "infrastructure": 0.030300977999285585, "output": 0.03333333333333333 } } ] }, { "seed": 8, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.984375, "infrastructure": 0.9329382757829725, "output": 1.5750000000000002 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.03125, "infrastructure": 0.03299360707206444, "output": 0.05 } } ] }, { "seed": 9, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.9791666666666666, "infrastructure": 0.9524587653805557, "output": 1.5666666666666667 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.0625, "infrastructure": 0.03987007123940198, "output": 0.1 } } ] }, { "seed": 10, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.984375, "infrastructure": 0.9425905081426994, "output": 1.5750000000000002 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.015625, "infrastructure": 0.02504019040696375, "output": 0.025 } } ] }, { "seed": 11, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.9739583333333334, "infrastructure": 0.953164811618429, "output": 1.5583333333333336 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.052083333333333336, "infrastructure": 0.032456283004211745, "output": 0.08333333333333334 } } ] }, { "seed": 12, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.984375, "infrastructure": 0.9505603240822575, "output": 1.5750000000000002 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.026041666666666668, "infrastructure": 0.027683455111424726, "output": 0.04166666666666667 } } ] }, { "seed": 13, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.9895833333333334, "infrastructure": 0.9495233077110319, "output": 1.5833333333333335 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.057291666666666664, "infrastructure": 0.03524595940797817, "output": 0.09166666666666667 } } ] }, { "seed": 14, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.984375, "infrastructure": 0.9712305522663524, "output": 1.5750000000000002 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.020833333333333332, "infrastructure": 0.03119671099391402, "output": 0.03333333333333333 } } ] }, { "seed": 15, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.9791666666666666, "infrastructure": 0.9577451414658983, "output": 1.5666666666666667 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.03125, "infrastructure": 0.02986446441682578, "output": 0.05 } } ] }, { "seed": 16, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.890625, "infrastructure": 0.9188657869516578, "output": 1.425 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.041666666666666664, "infrastructure": 0.038305395050855645, "output": 0.06666666666666667 } } ] }, { "seed": 17, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.984375, "infrastructure": 0.9447565833594499, "output": 1.5750000000000002 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.057291666666666664, "infrastructure": 0.036010424919118184, "output": 0.09166666666666667 } } ] }, { "seed": 18, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.8958333333333334, "infrastructure": 0.9307356176243294, "output": 1.4333333333333336 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.020833333333333332, "infrastructure": 0.028535170214272508, "output": 0.03333333333333333 } } ] }, { "seed": 19, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.984375, "infrastructure": 0.9676038141132332, "output": 1.5750000000000002 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.026041666666666668, "infrastructure": 0.029038034408187384, "output": 0.04166666666666667 } } ] }, { "seed": 20, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.890625, "infrastructure": 0.8980320024859868, "output": 1.425 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.052083333333333336, "infrastructure": 0.02945176328176311, "output": 0.08333333333333334 } } ] }, { "seed": 21, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.9895833333333334, "infrastructure": 0.928483564651592, "output": 1.5833333333333335 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.03125, "infrastructure": 0.02828612438172061, "output": 0.05 } } ] }, { "seed": 22, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.9166666666666666, "infrastructure": 0.9350906846931575, "output": 1.4666666666666668 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.046875, "infrastructure": 0.03635817159203267, "output": 0.07500000000000001 } } ] }, { "seed": 23, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.9791666666666666, "infrastructure": 0.9741822316658998, "output": 1.5666666666666667 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.046875, "infrastructure": 0.03143061492692302, "output": 0.07500000000000001 } } ] }, { "seed": 24, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.984375, "infrastructure": 0.967392793975101, "output": 1.5750000000000002 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.046875, "infrastructure": 0.03491000226532727, "output": 0.07500000000000001 } } ] }, { "seed": 25, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.828125, "infrastructure": 0.95515089710605, "output": 1.3250000000000002 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.03125, "infrastructure": 0.03105591102293431, "output": 0.05 } } ] }, { "seed": 26, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.828125, "infrastructure": 0.9533716090946366, "output": 1.3250000000000002 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.005208333333333333, "infrastructure": 0.02089757523567687, "output": 0.008333333333333333 } } ] }, { "seed": 27, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.984375, "infrastructure": 0.962191441316794, "output": 1.5750000000000002 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.015625, "infrastructure": 0.02757684938662701, "output": 0.025 } } ] }, { "seed": 28, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.9010416666666666, "infrastructure": 0.9788737054342715, "output": 1.4416666666666667 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.03125, "infrastructure": 0.02020868477877484, "output": 0.05 } } ] }, { "seed": 29, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.984375, "infrastructure": 0.9486695023289458, "output": 1.5750000000000002 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.057291666666666664, "infrastructure": 0.028311024485348606, "output": 0.09166666666666667 } } ] }, { "seed": 30, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.9114583333333334, "infrastructure": 0.9659277219021802, "output": 1.4583333333333335 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.036458333333333336, "infrastructure": 0.02773027588437057, "output": 0.05833333333333334 } } ] }, { "seed": 31, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.8958333333333334, "infrastructure": 0.9519486468885153, "output": 1.4333333333333336 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.036458333333333336, "infrastructure": 0.03765846395263731, "output": 0.05833333333333334 } } ] }, { "seed": 32, "arms": [ { "params": { "mixing": 0, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.96875, "infrastructure": 0.9653222485057695, "output": 1.55 } }, { "params": { "mixing": 0.9, "benefit": 1.6, "cost": 0.6, "mutation": 0.015, "groups": 12, "size": 16 }, "summary": { "cooperation": 0.036458333333333336, "infrastructure": 0.022284844482485053, "output": 0.05833333333333334 } } ] } ] }