{ "schema": "agent-swarm-evidence-v1", "model": "asteroid-button", "version": "1.0.0", "modelSha256": "d3405103c57634d28428508c985191bd45e80ad8fc59af288c0226cd42912f13", "primaryMetric": "workDelivered", "seeds": [ 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24 ], "runCount": 192, "armOutcomes": 576, "method": "24 paired seeds in each predeclared regime. Intervals are 2,000 resamples of paired primary-outcome differences. Null values are excluded from numeric aggregates and retain explicit valid counts. No biological or physical validation is implied.", "regimes": [ { "id": "calm-bulk", "label": "Before the asteroid", "description": "Clustered deposits, no fault: redundancy has overhead even when it is never used.", "aggregate": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 300, "min": 300, "max": 300, "median": 300, "standardError": 0 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 300, "min": 300, "max": 300, "median": 300, "standardError": 0 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 500, "min": 500, "max": 500, "median": 500, "standardError": 0 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 2251.451408333333, "min": 2251.07745, "max": 2251.72745, "median": 2251.45245, "standardError": 0.030264503001168497 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 374.125, "min": 374.125, "max": 374.125, "median": 374.125, "standardError": 0 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 239.95833333333334, "min": 225, "max": 251, "median": 240, "standardError": 1.2105801200470538 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 7, "min": 7, "max": 7, "median": 7, "standardError": 0 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.1332473799619242, "min": 0.13323104446995626, "max": 0.13326951501609982, "median": 0.13324731775933096, "standardError": 0.0000017912022024788525 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 100.00000000000001, "min": 100.00000000000001, "max": 100.00000000000001, "median": 100.00000000000001, "standardError": 0 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 200, "min": 200, "max": 200, "median": 200, "standardError": 0 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 200, "min": 200, "max": 200, "median": 200, "standardError": 0 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 2.5000000000000004, "min": 2.5000000000000004, "max": 2.5000000000000004, "median": 2.5000000000000004, "standardError": 0 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 1373.329395, "min": 1373.03877, "max": 1373.56377, "median": 1373.32627, "standardError": 0.02179722197596237 } } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 320, "min": 320, "max": 320, "median": 320, "standardError": 0 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 371.0208333333334, "min": 361.85, "max": 378.95, "median": 372.65, "standardError": 0.9840297061371605 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 428.9791666666666, "min": 421.05, "max": 438.15, "median": 427.35, "standardError": 0.9840297061371602 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 51.020833333333336, "min": 41.85, "max": 58.95, "median": 52.65, "standardError": 0.9840297061371605 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 4007.3279887499993, "min": 4000.78059, "max": 4016.49484, "median": 4006.74881, "standardError": 0.8828305230553318 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 9988.210250000002, "min": 9965.7, "max": 10014.232, "median": 9983.581, "standardError": 2.791783862508644 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 24, "min": 24, "max": 24, "median": 24, "standardError": 0 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 7553.25, "min": 7384, "max": 7681, "median": 7563, "standardError": 15.199190720256281 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 171.08333333333334, "min": 168, "max": 174, "median": 171, "standardError": 0.2617988681086975 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.07985379733536234, "min": 0.07967145805021639, "max": 0.07998439120712585, "median": 0.07986525113486556, "standardError": 0.00001758621356558064 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 200, "min": 200, "max": 200, "median": 200, "standardError": 0 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 200, "min": 200, "max": 200, "median": 200, "standardError": 0 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 1.6927083333333333, "min": 1.25, "max": 2.375, "median": 1.625, "standardError": 0.06065163890059775 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 2476.789580416667, "min": 2470.05364, "max": 2485.61789, "median": 2475.9711100000004, "standardError": 0.8490124923082505 } } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 320, "min": 320, "max": 320, "median": 320, "standardError": 0 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 350.1312500000001, "min": 340.25, "max": 357.8, "median": 349.475, "standardError": 1.060018681900589 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 449.86875000000003, "min": 442.2, "max": 459.75, "median": 450.525, "standardError": 1.0600186819005892 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 30.131249999999998, "min": 20.25, "max": 37.8, "median": 29.475, "standardError": 1.0600186819005886 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 3604.3301758333328, "min": 3597.51757, "max": 3612.09279, "median": 3605.032005, "standardError": 0.843933014004536 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 7487.476208333331, "min": 7469.84, "max": 7514.49, "median": 7486.4685, "standardError": 2.5030919292838982 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 18, "min": 18, "max": 18, "median": 18, "standardError": 0 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 5500.125, "min": 5380, "max": 5608, "median": 5512, "standardError": 13.863374813943539 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 122.20833333333333, "min": 121, "max": 124, "median": 122, "standardError": 0.19944821225566464 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.08878221136819969, "min": 0.08859130107576924, "max": 0.08895022572657153, "median": 0.08876481724080204, "standardError": 0.00002078875771377971 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 200, "min": 200, "max": 200, "median": 200, "standardError": 0 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 200, "min": 200, "max": 200, "median": 200, "standardError": 0 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 2.3072916666666665, "min": 1.75, "max": 2.625, "median": 2.375, "standardError": 0.043209108975191236 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 2227.1726425, "min": 2220.06212, "max": 2235.28734, "median": 2227.826555, "standardError": 0.8359626674872077 } } } ], "paired": [ { "arm": "distributed", "reference": "concentrated", "metric": "workDelivered", "interval": { "mean": 20, "lower95": 20, "upper95": 20, "bootstrapSamples": 2000, "paired": true } }, { "arm": "hybrid", "reference": "concentrated", "metric": "workDelivered", "interval": { "mean": 20, "lower95": 20, "upper95": 20, "bootstrapSamples": 2000, "paired": true } } ] }, { "id": "independent", "label": "Separate failures", "description": "Bodies fail independently with probability one half. The whole initial budget remains matched.", "aggregate": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 241.66666666666666, "min": 100, "max": 300, "median": 300, "standardError": 16.93622593118876 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 325, "min": 200, "max": 400, "median": 400, "standardError": 20.189321327181208 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 475, "min": 400, "max": 600, "median": 400, "standardError": 20.189321327181208 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 62.5, "min": 0, "max": 100, "median": 100, "standardError": 10.094660663590604 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 20.833333333333332, "min": 0, "max": 100, "median": 0, "standardError": 8.46811296559438 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 1671.9583862500003, "min": 815.13103, "max": 2186.1698, "median": 2185.8948, "standardError": 138.37350408150175 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 277.33450000000016, "min": 134.912, "max": 362.788, "median": 362.788, "standardError": 23.00330893376372 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.625, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0.10094660663590603 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 75, "min": 0, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 12.113592796308723 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.375, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 0, "standardError": 0.10094660663590603 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 100.25, "min": 40, "max": 141, "median": 130, "standardError": 9.107500094483363 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 3.25, "min": 2, "max": 4, "median": 4, "standardError": 0.20189321327181206 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.15221795803105562, "min": 0.12264956896723209, "max": 0.24535932436521565, "median": 0.13723571946838883, "standardError": 0.00876700532506476 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 154.16666666666669, "min": 100.00000000000001, "max": 200.00000000000003, "median": 200.00000000000003, "standardError": 10.389457216622949 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 87.5, "min": 0, "max": 200, "median": 100, "standardError": 16.277151230295583 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 145.83333333333334, "min": 100, "max": 200, "median": 100, "standardError": 10.389457216622946 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.6249999999999999, "min": -2.842170943040402e-16, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0.10094660663590604 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 9, "mean": 113.66666666666667, "min": 113, "max": 115, "median": 113, "standardError": 0.2886751345948129 }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.625, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0.10094660663590603 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 1.354166666666667, "min": 0, "max": 2.5000000000000004, "median": 2.5000000000000004, "standardError": 0.25973643041557376 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.375, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 0, "standardError": 0.10094660663590603 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 856.7356895833333, "min": 0, "max": 1370.93877, "median": 1370.70127, "standardError": 138.37529780375428 } } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 301.875, "min": 250, "max": 370, "median": 295, "standardError": 7.184250210492151 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 367.8229166666666, "min": 326.8, "max": 436.35, "median": 356.125, "standardError": 7.0091632436767854 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 432.1770833333333, "min": 363.65, "max": 473.2, "median": 443.875, "standardError": 7.009163243676785 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 30.947916666666668, "min": 10.9, "max": 50.9, "median": 30.675, "standardError": 2.0459164860311403 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 35, "min": 20, "max": 55, "median": 35, "standardError": 1.805787796286538 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 2523.6959391666664, "min": 2182.20515, "max": 2959.36541, "median": 2495.15237, "standardError": 48.98656933086478 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 6449.245749999998, "min": 5572.261, "max": 7563.357, "median": 6378.1505, "standardError": 125.19627211514683 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 11.416666666666666, "min": 8, "max": 16, "median": 11, "standardError": 0.5104582576962013 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 57.083333333333336, "min": 40, "max": 80, "median": 55, "standardError": 2.552291288481007 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 12.583333333333334, "min": 8, "max": 16, "median": 13, "standardError": 0.5104582576962013 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 2101.5833333333335, "min": 1817, "max": 2452, "median": 2073, "standardError": 41.93814098266786 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.4166666666666667, "min": 0, "max": 3, "median": 0, "standardError": 0.1988797126320791 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.11953598991174624, "min": 0.10716991348905529, "max": 0.13061944743764567, "median": 0.1202067728959573, "standardError": 0.001321824577201834 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 144.58333333333334, "min": 135, "max": 150, "median": 145, "standardError": 1.1623886368143699 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 157.29166666666666, "min": 110, "max": 230, "median": 152.5, "standardError": 7.2292880476799715 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 325.4166666666667, "min": 320, "max": 335, "median": 325, "standardError": 1.1623886368143699 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.4832708045219705, "min": 0.3384615384615385, "max": 0.696969696969697, "median": 0.469345579793341, "standardError": 0.02202435503883875 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 0, "mean": null, "min": null, "max": null, "median": null, "standardError": null }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 2.0833333333333335, "min": 1.75, "max": 2.25, "median": 2.125, "standardError": 0.03250789573356225 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 1087.9184975, "min": 746.57875, "max": 1523.96401, "median": 1059.3884699999999, "standardError": 48.976885933584136 } } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 308.75, "min": 250, "max": 385, "median": 302.5, "standardError": 7.947119157188391 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 385.99375000000003, "min": 325, "max": 455.9, "median": 377.5, "standardError": 7.647907092994769 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 414.00624999999997, "min": 344.1, "max": 475, "median": 422.5, "standardError": 7.64790709299477 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 33.49375, "min": 5, "max": 65, "median": 35, "standardError": 2.9793968125860353 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 43.75, "min": 20, "max": 65, "median": 45, "standardError": 2.7460445862303873 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 2263.0037845833335, "min": 1800.28775, "max": 2671.6604, "median": 2216.0854600000002, "standardError": 50.73911168160723 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 4829.497166666666, "min": 3903.445, "max": 5669.864, "median": 4678.045, "standardError": 108.37296492973617 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 8.708333333333334, "min": 5, "max": 12, "median": 8, "standardError": 0.44018756981354834 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 57.083333333333336, "min": 30, "max": 80, "median": 55, "standardError": 2.962884333699044 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 9.291666666666666, "min": 6, "max": 13, "median": 10, "standardError": 0.44018756981354834 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 1578.0833333333333, "min": 1322, "max": 1848, "median": 1555.5, "standardError": 34.96364139798318 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.8333333333333334, "min": 0, "max": 5, "median": 0, "standardError": 0.25300130797240716 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.13644638835793313, "min": 0.12325074556582491, "max": 0.15172918428926227, "median": 0.13907054767095506, "standardError": 0.0017259930985505673 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 142.5, "min": 135, "max": 145, "median": 145, "standardError": 0.6729773775727069 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 166.25, "min": 105, "max": 240, "median": 160, "standardError": 7.861170857218205 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 342.5, "min": 340, "max": 350, "median": 340, "standardError": 0.6729773775727069 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.4855318576706044, "min": 0.3088235294117647, "max": 0.7058823529411765, "median": 0.4671781756180733, "standardError": 0.02313535046388579 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 3, "mean": 117, "min": 89, "max": 173, "median": 89, "standardError": 28 }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.875, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0.0689596605459213 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 1.7864583333333333, "min": 1.625, "max": 1.875, "median": 1.875, "standardError": 0.021909479383037587 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 982.3216645833336, "min": 519.63063, "max": 1390.57828, "median": 935.70334, "standardError": 50.72803162901347 } } } ], "paired": [ { "arm": "distributed", "reference": "concentrated", "metric": "workDelivered", "interval": { "mean": 60.208333333333336, "lower95": 28.75, "upper95": 93.54166666666667, "bootstrapSamples": 2000, "paired": true } }, { "arm": "hybrid", "reference": "concentrated", "metric": "workDelivered", "interval": { "mean": 67.08333333333333, "lower95": 34.583333333333336, "upper95": 100.83333333333333, "bootstrapSamples": 2000, "paired": true } } ] }, { "id": "correlated", "label": "One shared scar", "description": "A single spatial damage field strikes bodies together. More nodes do not imply more independent survival chances.", "aggregate": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 108.33333333333333, "min": 100, "max": 300, "median": 100, "standardError": 8.333333333333334 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 108.33333333333333, "min": 100, "max": 300, "median": 100, "standardError": 8.333333333333334 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 691.6666666666666, "min": 500, "max": 700, "median": 700, "standardError": 8.333333333333334 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 935.3465454166667, "min": 877.78868, "max": 2251.57745, "median": 878.1511800000001, "standardError": 57.22743494633393 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 155.74383333333327, "min": 146.249, "max": 374.125, "median": 146.249, "standardError": 9.494833333333334 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.041666666666666664, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 0, "standardError": 0.04166666666666667 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 5, "min": 0, "max": 120, "median": 0, "standardError": 5 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.9583333333333334, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0.04166666666666669 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 55.458333333333336, "min": 34, "max": 245, "median": 48.5, "standardError": 8.288716611613214 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 1.25, "min": 1, "max": 7, "median": 1, "standardError": 0.25 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.11468644091246401, "min": 0.11386426231999854, "max": 0.13323992031683063, "median": 0.11387722886665883, "standardError": 0.0008066781647402173 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 100.00000000000001, "min": 100.00000000000001, "max": 100.00000000000001, "median": 100.00000000000001, "standardError": 0 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 8.333333333333334, "min": 0, "max": 200, "median": 0, "standardError": 8.333333333333334 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 200, "min": 200, "max": 200, "median": 200, "standardError": 0 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.041666666666666595, "min": -7.105427357601002e-17, "max": 1, "median": -7.105427357601002e-17, "standardError": 0.04166666666666667 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 1, "mean": 90, "min": 90, "max": 90, "median": 90, "standardError": null }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.9583333333333334, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0.04166666666666669 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 2.5000000000000004, "min": 2.5000000000000004, "max": 2.5000000000000004, "median": 2.5000000000000004, "standardError": 0 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.9583333333333334, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0.04166666666666669 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 57.22453208333334, "min": 0, "max": 1373.38877, "median": 0, "standardError": 57.22453208333334 } } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 202.5, "min": 120, "max": 320, "median": 180, "standardError": 17.861179667940043 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 226.56875000000002, "min": 120, "max": 375.35, "median": 210, "standardError": 22.42934676105654 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 573.43125, "min": 424.65, "max": 680, "median": 590, "standardError": 22.429346761056532 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 24.068749999999998, "min": 0, "max": 55.35, "median": 28.8, "standardError": 4.838324333857896 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 2539.031365, "min": 1529.02695, "max": 4016.49484, "median": 2224.894025, "standardError": 219.6755569897709 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 6397.840041666667, "min": 3923.444, "max": 10014.232, "median": 5645.059, "standardError": 538.1994588158012 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 9.833333333333334, "min": 0, "max": 24, "median": 7, "standardError": 2.1304101349259414 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 49.166666666666664, "min": 0, "max": 120, "median": 35, "standardError": 10.652050674629708 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 14.166666666666666, "min": 0, "max": 24, "median": 17, "standardError": 2.130410134925941 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 3745.4583333333335, "min": 1210, "max": 7640, "median": 2671.5, "standardError": 553.8435038312819 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 66.58333333333333, "min": 0, "max": 174, "median": 27.5, "standardError": 15.27298892886576 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.07943103984950863, "min": 0.07510854021209126, "max": 0.08622408129169173, "median": 0.0790763715867499, "standardError": 0.0004017101654205744 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 82.5, "min": 0, "max": 200, "median": 60, "standardError": 17.861179667940043 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 200, "min": 200, "max": 200, "median": 200, "standardError": 0 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.41250000000000003, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 0.30000000000000004, "standardError": 0.08930589833970021 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 10, "mean": 75.6, "min": 52, "max": 166, "median": 54, "standardError": 14.73861142260921 }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.5833333333333334, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0.10279899245732683 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 1.6927083333333333, "min": 1.25, "max": 2.375, "median": 1.625, "standardError": 0.06065163890059775 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.4583333333333333, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 0, "standardError": 0.10389457216622947 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 1008.4929566666668, "min": 0, "max": 2485.61789, "median": 694.142075, "standardError": 219.69931586694608 } } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 193.54166666666666, "min": 120, "max": 320, "median": 155, "standardError": 17.25364686998113 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 211.04791666666668, "min": 120, "max": 352.85, "median": 170, "standardError": 20.359025141263437 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 588.9520833333332, "min": 447.15, "max": 680, "median": 630, "standardError": 20.359025141263437 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 17.506249999999998, "min": 0, "max": 81.95, "median": 15, "standardError": 4.236879055975491 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 2230.1853691666665, "min": 1375.65545, "max": 3609.25378, "median": 1770.6055099999999, "standardError": 196.94107640878397 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 4716.503125, "min": 2929.573, "max": 7504.205, "median": 3916.819, "standardError": 402.43822002023995 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 7.083333333333333, "min": 0, "max": 18, "median": 4, "standardError": 1.5890438592038387 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 45.833333333333336, "min": 0, "max": 120, "median": 20, "standardError": 10.635030076793367 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 10.916666666666666, "min": 0, "max": 18, "median": 14, "standardError": 1.5890438592038387 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 2585.5416666666665, "min": 875, "max": 5608, "median": 1552, "standardError": 399.56197021295577 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 42.75, "min": 0, "max": 123, "median": 10, "standardError": 10.841120389717467 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.08681507236607672, "min": 0.07688462503617496, "max": 0.09063843685016575, "median": 0.08715274523479152, "standardError": 0.0005459510165819671 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 73.54166666666667, "min": 0, "max": 200, "median": 35, "standardError": 17.25364686998113 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 200, "min": 200, "max": 200, "median": 200, "standardError": 0 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.3677083333333333, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 0.175, "standardError": 0.08626823434990566 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 7, "mean": 152.57142857142858, "min": 58, "max": 172, "median": 169, "standardError": 15.818700721519667 }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.7083333333333334, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0.09477598811252416 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 2.3072916666666665, "min": 1.75, "max": 2.625, "median": 2.375, "standardError": 0.043209108975191236 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.4583333333333333, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 0, "standardError": 0.10389457216622947 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 853.0278358333335, "min": 0, "max": 2231.99249, "median": 393.73756000000003, "standardError": 196.9196958340235 } } } ], "paired": [ { "arm": "distributed", "reference": "concentrated", "metric": "workDelivered", "interval": { "mean": 94.16666666666667, "lower95": 62.916666666666664, "upper95": 128.75, "bootstrapSamples": 2000, "paired": true } }, { "arm": "hybrid", "reference": "concentrated", "metric": "workDelivered", "interval": { "mean": 85.20833333333333, "lower95": 55.625, "upper95": 117.70833333333333, "bootstrapSamples": 2000, "paired": true } } ] }, { "id": "compound", "label": "The asteroid button", "description": "Body loss, 90% remaining resource loss, corrupted sensors, blackout and rubble arrive together.", "aggregate": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 170.83333333333334, "min": 100, "max": 200, "median": 200, "standardError": 9.477598811252415 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 204.58333333333334, "min": 200, "max": 210, "median": 200, "standardError": 1.0389457216622948 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 55.416666666666664, "min": 50, "max": 60, "median": 60, "standardError": 1.0389457216622946 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 4.583333333333333, "min": 0, "max": 10, "median": 0, "standardError": 1.0389457216622948 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 29.166666666666668, "min": 0, "max": 100, "median": 0, "standardError": 9.477598811252411 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 540, "min": 540, "max": 540, "median": 540, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 1497.2458758333335, "min": 815.10603, "max": 2303.40433, "median": 815.2935299999999, "standardError": 154.60066884720197 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 249.22766666666658, "min": 134.912, "max": 384.328, "median": 134.912, "standardError": 25.912968611412285 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.4583333333333333, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 0, "standardError": 0.10389457216622947 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 55, "min": 0, "max": 120, "median": 0, "standardError": 12.467348659947538 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.5416666666666666, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0.10389457216622948 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 47.375, "min": 39, "max": 57, "median": 46.5, "standardError": 1.0158392332579438 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 4.75, "min": 2, "max": 8, "median": 2, "standardError": 0.6233674329973768 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.13690993054679948, "min": 0.08682800365436191, "max": 0.245366849745774, "median": 0.1226552103493186, "standardError": 0.013429037611168511 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 154.16666666666669, "min": 100.00000000000001, "max": 200.00000000000003, "median": 200.00000000000003, "standardError": 10.389457216622949 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 16.666666666666668, "min": 0, "max": 100, "median": 0, "standardError": 7.770873402002614 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 145.83333333333334, "min": 100, "max": 200, "median": 100, "standardError": 10.389457216622946 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.08333333333333315, "min": -2.842170943040402e-16, "max": 0.49999999999999994, "median": -2.842170943040402e-16, "standardError": 0.03885436701001308 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 0, "mean": null, "min": null, "max": null, "median": null, "standardError": null }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 1.354166666666667, "min": 0, "max": 2.5000000000000004, "median": 2.5000000000000004, "standardError": 0.25973643041557376 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.8333333333333334, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0.07770873402002612 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 682.0231791666665, "min": 0, "max": 1488.1233, "median": 0, "standardError": 154.60037788951854 } } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 188.54166666666666, "min": 135, "max": 235, "median": 195, "standardError": 7.51947451492964 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 244.6604166666667, "min": 210, "max": 269, "median": 252.675, "standardError": 5.2224874160970725 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 24.339583333333334, "min": 0, "max": 59, "median": 16.325, "standardError": 5.2224874160970725 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 19.660416666666666, "min": 0, "max": 34, "median": 25.175, "standardError": 3.0651751539407583 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 36.458333333333336, "min": 0, "max": 75, "median": 32.5, "standardError": 5.471261931730547 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 531, "min": 531, "max": 531, "median": 531, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 2432.0438591666666, "min": 1435.5764, "max": 3636.5669, "median": 2359.39457, "standardError": 160.31963273497783 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 6272.837499999999, "min": 3670.565, "max": 9424.183, "median": 6084.403, "standardError": 418.7946817236817 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 9.666666666666666, "min": 0, "max": 21, "median": 9, "standardError": 1.5377692608180553 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 48.333333333333336, "min": 0, "max": 105, "median": 45, "standardError": 7.688846304090275 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 14.333333333333334, "min": 3, "max": 24, "median": 15, "standardError": 1.5377692608180553 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 1320.4583333333333, "min": 1164, "max": 1504, "median": 1283.5, "standardError": 27.36991493149893 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 45.125, "min": 0, "max": 116, "median": 18.5, "standardError": 9.082016092495532 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.08126287645153453, "min": 0.06462138785499315, "max": 0.10446035957135943, "median": 0.07895965894519219, "standardError": 0.002683708121393139 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 144.58333333333334, "min": 135, "max": 150, "median": 145, "standardError": 1.1623886368143699 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 43.958333333333336, "min": 0, "max": 100, "median": 47.5, "standardError": 7.495343763970844 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 325.4166666666667, "min": 320, "max": 335, "median": 325, "standardError": 1.1623886368143699 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.13501830427553374, "min": 0, "max": 0.29850746268656714, "median": 0.1472956730769231, "standardError": 0.02289758847334802 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 0, "mean": null, "min": null, "max": null, "median": null, "standardError": null }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 2.0833333333333335, "min": 1.75, "max": 2.25, "median": 2.125, "standardError": 0.03250789573356225 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.2916666666666667, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 0, "standardError": 0.09477598811252412 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 996.2664175, "min": 0, "max": 2201.0405, "median": 923.84317, "standardError": 160.31655020021412 } } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 193.95833333333334, "min": 135, "max": 247.5, "median": 196.5, "standardError": 8.827499269752899 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 258.2291666666667, "min": 225, "max": 282.5, "median": 263, "standardError": 4.984303184064582 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 24.270833333333332, "min": 0, "max": 57.5, "median": 19.5, "standardError": 4.984303184064582 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 19.479166666666668, "min": 0, "max": 35, "median": 21.5, "standardError": 3.0561590175940223 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 44.791666666666664, "min": 0, "max": 90, "median": 45, "standardError": 6.957942799072803 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 517.5, "min": 517.5, "max": 517.5, "median": 517.5, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 2189.9823829166667, "min": 1280.45712, "max": 3278.58016, "median": 2080.65803, "standardError": 154.00145643368504 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 4691.913833333333, "min": 2719.959, "max": 7090.13, "median": 4461.8845, "standardError": 331.5177629726609 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 7.583333333333333, "min": 0, "max": 16, "median": 7, "standardError": 1.2112346477791478 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 50.833333333333336, "min": 0, "max": 105, "median": 47.5, "standardError": 8.124187064496805 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 10.416666666666666, "min": 2, "max": 18, "median": 11, "standardError": 1.2112346477791478 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 1014.5416666666666, "min": 876, "max": 1167, "median": 1025.5, "standardError": 22.347954804348383 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 34.458333333333336, "min": 0, "max": 86, "median": 22.5, "standardError": 6.705227024079383 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.0927150870429771, "min": 0.07548999511163977, "max": 0.11322312435998558, "median": 0.09174254635669592, "standardError": 0.002726870592636828 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 142.5, "min": 135, "max": 145, "median": 145, "standardError": 0.6729773775727069 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 51.458333333333336, "min": 0, "max": 107.5, "median": 51.5, "standardError": 8.695165483058835 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 342.5, "min": 340, "max": 350, "median": 340, "standardError": 0.6729773775727069 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.15043551841026262, "min": 0, "max": 0.3115942028985507, "median": 0.15147058823529413, "standardError": 0.02541462479114672 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 6, "mean": 40, "min": 40, "max": 40, "median": 40, "standardError": 0 }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.75, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0.0902893898143269 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 1.7864583333333333, "min": 1.625, "max": 1.875, "median": 1.875, "standardError": 0.021909479383037587 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.2916666666666667, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 0, "standardError": 0.09477598811252412 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 909.3002629166667, "min": 0, "max": 1998.24804, "median": 800.28841, "standardError": 153.99377856101435 } } } ], "paired": [ { "arm": "distributed", "reference": "concentrated", "metric": "workDelivered", "interval": { "mean": 17.708333333333332, "lower95": 1.9791666666666667, "upper95": 33.854166666666664, "bootstrapSamples": 2000, "paired": true } }, { "arm": "hybrid", "reference": "concentrated", "metric": "workDelivered", "interval": { "mean": 23.125, "lower95": 6.458333333333333, "upper95": 39.5625, "bootstrapSamples": 2000, "paired": true } } ] }, { "id": "blackout", "label": "Radio silence", "description": "Only communication fails. Existing local plans and observations remain available.", "aggregate": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 300, "min": 300, "max": 300, "median": 300, "standardError": 0 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 400, "min": 400, "max": 400, "median": 400, "standardError": 0 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 400, "min": 400, "max": 400, "median": 400, "standardError": 0 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 100, "min": 100, "max": 100, "median": 100, "standardError": 0 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 2184.9354249999997, "min": 2184.6948, "max": 2185.0698, "median": 2184.9198, "standardError": 0.01848009235382157 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 362.78800000000024, "min": 362.788, "max": 362.788, "median": 362.788, "standardError": 4.7410688707049024e-14 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 91.625, "min": 82, "max": 97, "median": 91, "standardError": 0.7392036941528873 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 4, "min": 4, "max": 4, "median": 4, "standardError": 0 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.13730382925105009, "min": 0.13729538526648183, "max": 0.13731895183947834, "median": 0.1373048109249394, "standardError": 0.000001161330329146493 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 154.16666666666669, "min": 100.00000000000001, "max": 200.00000000000003, "median": 200.00000000000003, "standardError": 10.389457216622949 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 145.83333333333334, "min": 100, "max": 200, "median": 100, "standardError": 10.389457216622946 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 145.83333333333334, "min": 100, "max": 200, "median": 100, "standardError": 10.389457216622946 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 13, "mean": 113.15384615384616, "min": 111, "max": 115, "median": 113, "standardError": 0.3171619712013585 }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.4583333333333333, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 0, "standardError": 0.10389457216622947 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 1.354166666666667, "min": 0, "max": 2.5000000000000004, "median": 2.5000000000000004, "standardError": 0.25973643041557376 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 1369.7127283333332, "min": 1369.58877, "max": 1369.86377, "median": 1369.71377, "standardError": 0.012543327686238176 } } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 470, "min": 470, "max": 470, "median": 470, "standardError": 0 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 533.49375, "min": 531.35, "max": 538.6, "median": 532.925, "standardError": 0.43302642943238273 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 266.50624999999997, "min": 261.4, "max": 268.65, "median": 267.07500000000005, "standardError": 0.43302642943238 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 63.49375, "min": 61.35, "max": 68.6, "median": 62.925, "standardError": 0.4330264294323806 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 3709.850312916667, "min": 3705.18923, "max": 3712.68169, "median": 3710.192035, "standardError": 0.3771509188873353 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 9533.274291666663, "min": 9519.97, "max": 9539.128, "median": 9534.657500000001, "standardError": 1.1478062479772866 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 24, "min": 24, "max": 24, "median": 24, "standardError": 0 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 2296.2083333333335, "min": 2266, "max": 2333, "median": 2295, "standardError": 3.900008903123741 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 5.041666666666667, "min": 4, "max": 6, "median": 5, "standardError": 0.11227500313294324 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.1266897777733326, "min": 0.12659313106107567, "max": 0.12684912194805872, "median": 0.126678079176252, "standardError": 0.00001288640170526664 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 144.58333333333334, "min": 135, "max": 150, "median": 145, "standardError": 1.1623886368143699 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 325.4166666666667, "min": 320, "max": 335, "median": 325, "standardError": 1.1623886368143699 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 325.4166666666667, "min": 320, "max": 335, "median": 325, "standardError": 1.1623886368143699 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 24, "mean": 87.70833333333333, "min": 82, "max": 89, "median": 88, "standardError": 0.4147601308992641 }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 2.0833333333333335, "min": 1.75, "max": 2.25, "median": 2.125, "standardError": 0.03250789573356225 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 2274.07287125, "min": 2269.48783, "max": 2276.53029, "median": 2274.4987149999997, "standardError": 0.3895572791994561 } } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 485, "min": 485, "max": 485, "median": 485, "standardError": 0 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 540.4979166666667, "min": 535.35, "max": 544.8, "median": 542.325, "standardError": 0.7118782512660441 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 259.5020833333333, "min": 255.2, "max": 264.65, "median": 257.67499999999995, "standardError": 0.7118782512660454 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 55.49791666666669, "min": 50.35, "max": 59.8, "median": 57.325, "standardError": 0.711878251266046 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 3338.863298333333, "min": 3334.45153, "max": 3343.58297, "median": 3337.3634949999996, "standardError": 0.6276257433059802 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 7119.971083333334, "min": 7111.899, "max": 7128.35, "median": 7120.687, "standardError": 1.0074920665647105 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 18, "min": 18, "max": 18, "median": 18, "standardError": 0 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 1706.8333333333333, "min": 1663, "max": 1760, "median": 1709, "standardError": 4.189646774683799 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 1.625, "min": 1, "max": 2, "median": 2, "standardError": 0.10094660663590603 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.14525913486582231, "min": 0.1450539749808689, "max": 0.14545120715909274, "median": 0.1453242984868937, "standardError": 0.000027298225897125064 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 142.5, "min": 135, "max": 145, "median": 145, "standardError": 0.6729773775727069 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 342.5, "min": 340, "max": 350, "median": 340, "standardError": 0.6729773775727069 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 342.5, "min": 340, "max": 350, "median": 340, "standardError": 0.6729773775727069 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 24, "mean": 40, "min": 40, "max": 40, "median": 40, "standardError": 0 }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 1.7864583333333333, "min": 1.625, "max": 1.875, "median": 1.875, "standardError": 0.021909479383037587 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 2058.1811783333333, "min": 2053.66941, "max": 2062.85085, "median": 2056.8844950000002, "standardError": 0.6108709512911858 } } } ], "paired": [ { "arm": "distributed", "reference": "concentrated", "metric": "workDelivered", "interval": { "mean": 170, "lower95": 170, "upper95": 170, "bootstrapSamples": 2000, "paired": true } }, { "arm": "hybrid", "reference": "concentrated", "metric": "workDelivered", "interval": { "mean": 185, "lower95": 185, "upper95": 185, "bootstrapSamples": 2000, "paired": true } } ] }, { "id": "resource-loss", "label": "The missing deposits", "description": "Remove 90% of remaining material, leaving bodies and links healthy.", "aggregate": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 210, "min": 210, "max": 210, "median": 210, "standardError": 0 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 220, "min": 220, "max": 220, "median": 220, "standardError": 0 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 40, "min": 40, "max": 40, "median": 40, "standardError": 0 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 10, "min": 10, "max": 10, "median": 10, "standardError": 0 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 540, "min": 540, "max": 540, "median": 540, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 2298.6454450000006, "min": 2298.42357, "max": 2298.79857, "median": 2298.67357, "standardError": 0.02313283259440277 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 383.1949999999999, "min": 383.195, "max": 383.195, "median": 383.195, "standardError": 2.3705344353524512e-14 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 117.875, "min": 109, "max": 124, "median": 119, "standardError": 0.9253133037760387 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 4, "min": 4, "max": 4, "median": 4, "standardError": 0 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.09135815223859384, "min": 0.09135206657870776, "max": 0.0913669711530504, "median": 0.0913570342406291, "standardError": 9.194173753288204e-7 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 154.16666666666669, "min": 100.00000000000001, "max": 200.00000000000003, "median": 200.00000000000003, "standardError": 10.389457216622949 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 55.833333333333336, "min": 10, "max": 110, "median": 10, "standardError": 10.38945721662295 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 145.83333333333334, "min": 100, "max": 200, "median": 100, "standardError": 10.389457216622946 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.3062499999999998, "min": 0.09999999999999974, "max": 0.5499999999999999, "median": 0.09999999999999974, "standardError": 0.04675255747480328 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 0, "mean": null, "min": null, "max": null, "median": null, "standardError": null }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 1.354166666666667, "min": 0, "max": 2.5000000000000004, "median": 2.5000000000000004, "standardError": 0.25973643041557376 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 1483.4227483333334, "min": 1483.29254, "max": 1483.54254, "median": 1483.41754, "standardError": 0.01709012546136354 } } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 269, "min": 269, "max": 269, "median": 269, "standardError": 0 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 269, "min": 269, "max": 269, "median": 269, "standardError": 0 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 531, "min": 531, "max": 531, "median": 531, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 3976.0043349999996, "min": 3974.82621, "max": 3978.37621, "median": 3975.8012099999996, "standardError": 0.18987214722455906 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 10273.495999999992, "min": 10273.496, "max": 10273.496, "median": 10273.496, "standardError": 1.5171420386255688e-12 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 24, "min": 24, "max": 24, "median": 24, "standardError": 0 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 2135.125, "min": 2088, "max": 2230, "median": 2127, "standardError": 7.594885888982577 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 24.583333333333332, "min": 24, "max": 27, "median": 24, "standardError": 0.16936225931188761 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.06765586547327403, "min": 0.06761552605994829, "max": 0.06767591489334703, "median": 0.06765931850990496, "standardError": 0.000003230136939040377 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 144.58333333333334, "min": 135, "max": 150, "median": 145, "standardError": 1.1623886368143699 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 124.41666666666667, "min": 119, "max": 134, "median": 124, "standardError": 1.16238863681437 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 325.4166666666667, "min": 320, "max": 335, "median": 325, "standardError": 1.1623886368143699 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.3821507138694639, "min": 0.371875, "max": 0.4, "median": 0.38153846153846155, "standardError": 0.0021866594897554325 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 0, "mean": null, "min": null, "max": null, "median": null, "standardError": null }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 2.0833333333333335, "min": 1.75, "max": 2.25, "median": 2.125, "standardError": 0.03250789573356225 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 2540.2268933333335, "min": 2539.22481, "max": 2542.74981, "median": 2540.02481, "standardError": 0.1666887440087806 } } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 282.5, "min": 282.5, "max": 282.5, "median": 282.5, "standardError": 0 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 282.5, "min": 282.5, "max": 282.5, "median": 282.5, "standardError": 0 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 517.5, "min": 517.5, "max": 517.5, "median": 517.5, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 3570.1654541666667, "min": 3566.45138, "max": 3572.46239, "median": 3570.36679, "standardError": 0.33391714768608594 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 7641.818375, "min": 7636.657, "max": 7648.253, "median": 7641.186, "standardError": 0.6997301700761758 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 18, "min": 18, "max": 18, "median": 18, "standardError": 0 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 1607.4583333333333, "min": 1491, "max": 1659, "median": 1623, "standardError": 9.963698451666872 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 18.916666666666668, "min": 17, "max": 22, "median": 18, "standardError": 0.3064326454273024 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.0791280013589498, "min": 0.07907710967031659, "max": 0.0792103887766408, "median": 0.07912352352332197, "standardError": 0.00000740345660160396 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 142.5, "min": 135, "max": 145, "median": 145, "standardError": 0.6729773775727069 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 140, "min": 137.5, "max": 147.5, "median": 137.5, "standardError": 0.6729773775727069 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 342.5, "min": 340, "max": 350, "median": 340, "standardError": 0.6729773775727069 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.40870706978443533, "min": 0.40441176470588236, "max": 0.42142857142857143, "median": 0.40441176470588236, "standardError": 0.0011518760343749964 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 24, "mean": 40, "min": 40, "max": 40, "median": 40, "standardError": 0 }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 1.7864583333333333, "min": 1.625, "max": 1.875, "median": 1.875, "standardError": 0.021909479383037587 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 2289.4833341666667, "min": 2285.96926, "max": 2292.03027, "median": 2289.675515, "standardError": 0.3114989565385587 } } } ], "paired": [ { "arm": "distributed", "reference": "concentrated", "metric": "workDelivered", "interval": { "mean": 59, "lower95": 59, "upper95": 59, "bootstrapSamples": 2000, "paired": true } }, { "arm": "hybrid", "reference": "concentrated", "metric": "workDelivered", "interval": { "mean": 72.5, "lower95": 72.5, "upper95": 72.5, "bootstrapSamples": 2000, "paired": true } } ] }, { "id": "sensor-loss", "label": "Unreliable eyes", "description": "Corrupt local observations while retaining intact bodies, material and links.", "aggregate": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 300, "min": 300, "max": 300, "median": 300, "standardError": 0 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 400, "min": 400, "max": 400, "median": 400, "standardError": 0 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 400, "min": 400, "max": 400, "median": 400, "standardError": 0 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 100, "min": 100, "max": 100, "median": 100, "standardError": 0 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 2183.160265416667, "min": 2159.32174, "max": 2184.8948, "median": 2184.3948, "standardError": 1.0670698886231254 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 362.55179166666693, "min": 358.253, "max": 362.788, "median": 362.788, "standardError": 0.19277303222573133 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 72.95833333333333, "min": 62, "max": 90, "median": 72, "standardError": 1.3613175186096116 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 4, "min": 4, "max": 4, "median": 4, "standardError": 0 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.13741623538773276, "min": 0.13730638199384085, "max": 0.13893251499664735, "median": 0.13733781092372255, "standardError": 0.00006783829742366219 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 154.16666666666669, "min": 100.00000000000001, "max": 200.00000000000003, "median": 200.00000000000003, "standardError": 10.389457216622949 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 145.83333333333334, "min": 100, "max": 200, "median": 100, "standardError": 10.389457216622946 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 145.83333333333334, "min": 100, "max": 200, "median": 100, "standardError": 10.389457216622946 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 13, "mean": 113.46153846153847, "min": 111, "max": 116, "median": 113, "standardError": 0.38589530623826696 }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.4583333333333333, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 0, "standardError": 0.10389457216622947 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 1.354166666666667, "min": 0, "max": 2.5000000000000004, "median": 2.5000000000000004, "standardError": 0.25973643041557376 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 1367.9375687499999, "min": 1344.11571, "max": 1369.68877, "median": 1369.18877, "standardError": 1.0665636611761231 } } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 469.7916666666667, "min": 465, "max": 470, "median": 470, "standardError": 0.2083333333333335 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 531.0124999999998, "min": 530, "max": 533.15, "median": 530.9, "standardError": 0.19579478498184438 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 268.9875, "min": 266.85, "max": 270, "median": 269.1, "standardError": 0.19579478498184508 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 61.22083333333334, "min": 60, "max": 65.9, "median": 60.9, "standardError": 0.28231247249387326 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 3698.61053375, "min": 3692.86423, "max": 3701.38018, "median": 3698.85378, "standardError": 0.42458387436347106 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 9534.657791666665, "min": 9519.97, "max": 9542.959, "median": 9535.296, "standardError": 1.0652447564897978 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 24, "min": 24, "max": 24, "median": 24, "standardError": 0 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 1826.4166666666667, "min": 1788, "max": 1870, "median": 1824.5, "standardError": 4.548019423477488 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 5.375, "min": 4, "max": 6, "median": 5, "standardError": 0.1320476966966806 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.1270184586493848, "min": 0.12572296794330093, "max": 0.12727248314745132, "median": 0.12705694489465258, "standardError": 0.00005818606933061491 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 144.58333333333334, "min": 135, "max": 150, "median": 145, "standardError": 1.1623886368143699 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 325.2083333333333, "min": 320, "max": 335, "median": 325, "standardError": 1.1452155778746478 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 325.4166666666667, "min": 320, "max": 335, "median": 325, "standardError": 1.1623886368143699 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.9993686868686869, "min": 0.9848484848484849, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0.0006313131313131311 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 24, "mean": 87.79166666666667, "min": 83, "max": 89, "median": 88, "standardError": 0.34567287180153 }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 2.0833333333333335, "min": 1.75, "max": 2.25, "median": 2.125, "standardError": 0.03250789573356225 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 2262.8330920833328, "min": 2257.13783, "max": 2265.70378, "median": 2263.21046, "standardError": 0.416453449609502 } } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 485, "min": 485, "max": 485, "median": 485, "standardError": 0 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 533.1062499999999, "min": 526.35, "max": 541.65, "median": 533.325, "standardError": 0.8036844080342674 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 266.89375, "min": 258.35, "max": 273.65, "median": 266.67499999999995, "standardError": 0.803684408034267 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 48.10625000000001, "min": 41.35, "max": 56.65, "median": 48.325, "standardError": 0.8036844080342677 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 3334.592033333333, "min": 3322.7662, "max": 3340.49721, "median": 3334.3377250000003, "standardError": 1.0020896203447913 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 7130.966124999999, "min": 7108.152, "max": 7144.953, "median": 7129.6695, "standardError": 2.1584887085077584 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 18, "min": 18, "max": 18, "median": 18, "standardError": 0 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 1361.75, "min": 1335, "max": 1397, "median": 1362.5, "standardError": 3.974670709175392 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 4.875, "min": 2, "max": 9, "median": 5, "standardError": 0.4827176238214491 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.14544538079588165, "min": 0.1451879675888681, "max": 0.14596272222382398, "median": 0.14545617268133856, "standardError": 0.000043740764379674185 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 142.5, "min": 135, "max": 145, "median": 145, "standardError": 0.6729773775727069 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 342.5, "min": 340, "max": 350, "median": 340, "standardError": 0.6729773775727069 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 342.5, "min": 340, "max": 350, "median": 340, "standardError": 0.6729773775727069 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 24, "mean": 40, "min": 40, "max": 40, "median": 40, "standardError": 0 }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 1.7864583333333333, "min": 1.625, "max": 1.875, "median": 1.875, "standardError": 0.021909479383037587 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 2053.909913333334, "min": 2041.98408, "max": 2059.81098, "median": 2053.6905100000004, "standardError": 0.9921228810017121 } } } ], "paired": [ { "arm": "distributed", "reference": "concentrated", "metric": "workDelivered", "interval": { "mean": 169.79166666666666, "lower95": 169.375, "upper95": 170, "bootstrapSamples": 2000, "paired": true } }, { "arm": "hybrid", "reference": "concentrated", "metric": "workDelivered", "interval": { "mean": 185, "lower95": 185, "upper95": 185, "bootstrapSamples": 2000, "paired": true } } ] }, { "id": "rubble", "label": "A road becomes a wall", "description": "One new physical barrier tests the frozen contact-detour policy alone.", "aggregate": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 200, "min": 200, "max": 200, "median": 200, "standardError": 0 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 300, "min": 300, "max": 300, "median": 300, "standardError": 0 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 500, "min": 500, "max": 500, "median": 500, "standardError": 0 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 100, "min": 100, "max": 100, "median": 100, "standardError": 0 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 2248.081616666667, "min": 2247.92745, "max": 2248.30245, "median": 2248.07745, "standardError": 0.01646160075803329 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 374.125, "min": 374.125, "max": 374.125, "median": 374.125, "standardError": 0 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 105.16666666666667, "min": 99, "max": 114, "median": 105, "standardError": 0.6584640303213634 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 8, "min": 8, "max": 8, "median": 8, "standardError": 0 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.0889647416627169, "min": 0.08895600323559988, "max": 0.08897084290545507, "median": 0.08896490644341856, "standardError": 6.514342144338001e-7 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 154.16666666666669, "min": 100.00000000000001, "max": 200.00000000000003, "median": 200.00000000000003, "standardError": 10.389457216622949 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 45.833333333333336, "min": 0, "max": 100, "median": 0, "standardError": 10.38945721662295 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 145.83333333333334, "min": 100, "max": 200, "median": 100, "standardError": 10.389457216622946 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.2291666666666665, "min": -2.842170943040402e-16, "max": 0.49999999999999994, "median": -2.842170943040402e-16, "standardError": 0.05194728608311478 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 0, "mean": null, "min": null, "max": null, "median": null, "standardError": null }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 1, "min": 1, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 1.354166666666667, "min": 0, "max": 2.5000000000000004, "median": 2.5000000000000004, "standardError": 0.25973643041557376 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.5416666666666666, "min": 0, "max": 1, "median": 1, "standardError": 0.10389457216622948 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 1432.8589200000004, "min": 1432.72142, "max": 1432.99642, "median": 1432.8589200000001, "standardError": 0.01165631010300083 } } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 440, "min": 440, "max": 440, "median": 440, "standardError": 0 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 489.5833333333333, "min": 485, "max": 490, "median": 490, "standardError": 0.28815169783671873 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 310.4166666666667, "min": 310, "max": 315, "median": 310, "standardError": 0.2881516978367186 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 49.583333333333336, "min": 45, "max": 50, "median": 50, "standardError": 0.28815169783671846 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 3757.6786799999995, "min": 3671.0258, "max": 3766.93649, "median": 3765.3453200000004, "standardError": 5.409501837599733 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 9630.657625000003, "min": 9384.591, "max": 9654.073, "median": 9652.795, "standardError": 15.430230296849519 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 24, "min": 24, "max": 24, "median": 24, "standardError": 0 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 2787.5416666666665, "min": 2741, "max": 2946, "median": 2774, "standardError": 9.949870577897393 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 31.833333333333332, "min": 25, "max": 38, "median": 32.5, "standardError": 0.7011033402572026 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.1170992670652395, "min": 0.11680579211286109, "max": 0.11985750676524123, "median": 0.11685515207232268, "standardError": 0.00017215530422433974 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 144.58333333333334, "min": 135, "max": 150, "median": 145, "standardError": 1.1623886368143699 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 295.4166666666667, "min": 290, "max": 305, "median": 295, "standardError": 1.1623886368143699 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 325.4166666666667, "min": 320, "max": 335, "median": 325, "standardError": 1.1623886368143699 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.9077836886372332, "min": 0.90625, "max": 0.9104477611940298, "median": 0.9076923076923077, "standardError": 0.00032636708802319565 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 24, "mean": 88.33333333333333, "min": 86, "max": 89, "median": 88, "standardError": 0.15541746804005224 }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 2.0833333333333335, "min": 1.75, "max": 2.25, "median": 2.125, "standardError": 0.03250789573356225 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 2321.9012383333325, "min": 2235.6494, "max": 2330.66009, "median": 2329.60642, "standardError": 5.393918746376676 } } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "metrics": { "workDelivered": { "n": 24, "mean": 430, "min": 430, "max": 430, "median": 430, "standardError": 0 }, "materialExtracted": { "n": 24, "mean": 484.69375000000014, "min": 475, "max": 494.95, "median": 484.275, "standardError": 1.1453328122889865 }, "materialRemaining": { "n": 24, "mean": 315.30625, "min": 305.05, "max": 325, "median": 315.725, "standardError": 1.1453328122889865 }, "materialInTransit": { "n": 24, "mean": 54.69374999999999, "min": 45, "max": 64.95, "median": 54.275, "standardError": 1.1453328122889856 }, "cargoLost": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "resourceDestroyed": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energySpent": { "n": 24, "mean": 3302.9378737500006, "min": 3145.76431, "max": 3400.32777, "median": 3245.3114299999997, "standardError": 16.93356100437552 }, "distance": { "n": 24, "mean": 7060.377, "min": 6683.25, "max": 7240.401, "median": 6966.2095, "standardError": 31.5098382135287 }, "survivors": { "n": 24, "mean": 18, "min": 18, "max": 18, "median": 18, "standardError": 0 }, "capacitySurviving": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "shockDeaths": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "messages": { "n": 24, "mean": 2249.0416666666665, "min": 2125, "max": 2436, "median": 2286.5, "standardError": 17.35817052391173 }, "staleVisits": { "n": 24, "mean": 20.875, "min": 11, "max": 32, "median": 20, "standardError": 1.3136856273615205 }, "workPerEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.13026567952567927, "min": 0.1264583973357133, "max": 0.13669174110915477, "median": 0.13249884005645812, "standardError": 0.0006662503821207143 }, "initialCapacity": { "n": 24, "mean": 120, "min": 120, "max": 120, "median": 120, "standardError": 0 }, "initialEnergy": { "n": 24, "mean": 18000, "min": 18000, "max": 18000, "median": 18000, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 142.5, "min": 135, "max": 145, "median": 145, "standardError": 0.6729773775727069 }, "postShockWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 287.5, "min": 285, "max": 295, "median": 285, "standardError": 0.6729773775727069 }, "counterfactualPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 342.5, "min": 340, "max": 350, "median": 340, "standardError": 0.6729773775727069 }, "retention": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.8394019201883648, "min": 0.8382352941176471, "max": 0.8428571428571429, "median": 0.8382352941176471, "standardError": 0.00031285521921295797 }, "recoveryTicks": { "n": 24, "mean": 40, "min": 40, "max": 40, "median": 40, "standardError": 0 }, "recoveryCensored": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "preShockRate": { "n": 24, "mean": 1.7864583333333333, "min": 1.625, "max": 1.875, "median": 1.875, "standardError": 0.021909479383037587 }, "zeroPostWork": { "n": 24, "mean": 0, "min": 0, "max": 0, "median": 0, "standardError": 0 }, "energyAfterShock": { "n": 24, "mean": 2022.25575375, "min": 1865.45719, "max": 2119.77666, "median": 1964.39181, "standardError": 16.916923652835447 } } } ], "paired": [ { "arm": "distributed", "reference": "concentrated", "metric": "workDelivered", "interval": { "mean": 240, "lower95": 240, "upper95": 240, "bootstrapSamples": 2000, "paired": true } }, { "arm": "hybrid", "reference": "concentrated", "metric": "workDelivered", "interval": { "mean": 230, "lower95": 230, "upper95": 230, "bootstrapSamples": 2000, "paired": true } } ] } ], "runs": [ { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 1, "params": { "seed": 1, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.45245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 240, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13324731775933096, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.33877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 372.65, "materialRemaining": 427.35, "materialInTransit": 52.65, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4001.40689, "distance": 9983.581, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7384, "staleVisits": 172, "workPerEnergy": 0.07997187203030301, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2472.55494 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 346.55, "materialRemaining": 453.45, "materialInTransit": 26.55, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3605.92769, "distance": 7495.315, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5425, "staleVisits": 122, "workPerEnergy": 0.08874276670796717, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2229.24724 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 2, "params": { "seed": 2, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.57745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 245, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13323992031683082, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.36377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 361.85, "materialRemaining": 438.15, "materialInTransit": 41.85, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4016.49484, "distance": 10014.232, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7540, "staleVisits": 174, "workPerEnergy": 0.07967145805021639, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2485.61789 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 347.45, "materialRemaining": 452.55, "materialInTransit": 27.45, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3605.58439, "distance": 7496.66, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5437, "staleVisits": 121, "workPerEnergy": 0.08875121628391146, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2228.62894 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 3, "params": { "seed": 3, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.35245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 236, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13325323630477137, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.26377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 374, "materialRemaining": 426, "materialInTransit": 54, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4006.6084, "distance": 9979.749, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7648, "staleVisits": 170, "workPerEnergy": 0.07986804999394558, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.5, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2474.93145 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 349.25, "materialRemaining": 450.75, "materialInTransit": 29.25, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3607.03093, "distance": 7490.257, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5577, "staleVisits": 123, "workPerEnergy": 0.08871562395620557, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2229.30048 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 4, "params": { "seed": 4, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.72745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 251, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13323104446995626, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.56377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 374.45, "materialRemaining": 425.55, "materialInTransit": 54.45, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4003.49224, "distance": 9978.472, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7542, "staleVisits": 169, "workPerEnergy": 0.07993021621213058, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2473.94029 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 348.8, "materialRemaining": 451.2, "materialInTransit": 28.8, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3604.49947, "distance": 7491.518, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5446, "staleVisits": 122, "workPerEnergy": 0.08877792964793348, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2227.51902 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 5, "params": { "seed": 5, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.50245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 242, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13324435868376439, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.43877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 372.2, "materialRemaining": 427.8, "materialInTransit": 52.2, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4007.27306, "distance": 9984.858, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7600, "staleVisits": 171, "workPerEnergy": 0.07985480285640222, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2476.04611 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 349.25, "materialRemaining": 450.75, "materialInTransit": 29.25, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3605.56454, "distance": 7486.375, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5541, "staleVisits": 121, "workPerEnergy": 0.08875170483367059, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2228.13409 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 6, "params": { "seed": 6, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.42745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 239, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13324879734640147, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.28877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 369.95, "materialRemaining": 430.05, "materialInTransit": 49.95, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4009.10388, "distance": 9991.244, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7580, "staleVisits": 168, "workPerEnergy": 0.07981833587451488, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2478.50193 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 354.2, "materialRemaining": 445.8, "materialInTransit": 34.2, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3603.08309, "distance": 7478.78, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5598, "staleVisits": 124, "workPerEnergy": 0.08881282838627146, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2225.70264 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 7, "params": { "seed": 7, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.42745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 239, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13324879734640124, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.26377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 373.55, "materialRemaining": 426.45, "materialInTransit": 53.55, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4004.87456, "distance": 9981.026, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7560, "staleVisits": 172, "workPerEnergy": 0.07990262737419067, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2473.67261 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 352.85, "materialRemaining": 447.15, "materialInTransit": 32.85, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3603.37297, "distance": 7486.494, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5531, "staleVisits": 123, "workPerEnergy": 0.08880568353382468, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2225.96752 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 8, "params": { "seed": 8, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.17745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 229, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13326359502454063, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.03877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 366.8, "materialRemaining": 433.2, "materialInTransit": 46.8, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4011.71703, "distance": 10000.184, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7554, "staleVisits": 172, "workPerEnergy": 0.07976634383947269, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2480.59008 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 346.1, "materialRemaining": 453.9, "materialInTransit": 26.1, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3609.29905, "distance": 7501.769, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5511, "staleVisits": 122, "workPerEnergy": 0.08865987434585029, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2231.4936 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 9, "params": { "seed": 9, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.45245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 240, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13324731775933096, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.41377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 363.2, "materialRemaining": 436.8, "materialInTransit": 43.2, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4011.74634, "distance": 10010.401, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7406, "staleVisits": 171, "workPerEnergy": 0.0797657609640796, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2481.54439 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 342.05, "materialRemaining": 457.95, "materialInTransit": 22.05, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3608.89794, "distance": 7504.205, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5380, "staleVisits": 121, "workPerEnergy": 0.08866972826021094, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2231.99249 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 10, "params": { "seed": 10, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.32745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 235, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13325471602328512, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.21377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 372.2, "materialRemaining": 427.8, "materialInTransit": 52.2, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4004.92306, "distance": 9984.858, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7506, "staleVisits": 172, "workPerEnergy": 0.07990165988312094, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2475.89611 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 351.5, "materialRemaining": 448.5, "materialInTransit": 31.5, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3601.98007, "distance": 7486.443, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5442, "staleVisits": 124, "workPerEnergy": 0.08884002503107313, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2226.32462 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 11, "params": { "seed": 11, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.47745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 241, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13324583820511918, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.41377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 376.7, "materialRemaining": 423.3, "materialInTransit": 56.7, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4001.21141, "distance": 9972.086, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7544, "staleVisits": 171, "workPerEnergy": 0.0799757790593324, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2471.30946 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 355.55, "materialRemaining": 444.45, "materialInTransit": 35.55, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3600.3596, "distance": 7474.948, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5545, "staleVisits": 122, "workPerEnergy": 0.08888001087741441, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2223.45415 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 12, "params": { "seed": 12, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.42745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 239, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.1332487973464013, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.26377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 372.65, "materialRemaining": 427.35, "materialInTransit": 52.65, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4006.78189, "distance": 9983.581, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7599, "staleVisits": 172, "workPerEnergy": 0.07986459171816555, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2475.40494 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 357.35, "materialRemaining": 442.65, "materialInTransit": 37.35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3597.51757, "distance": 7469.857, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5517, "staleVisits": 123, "workPerEnergy": 0.08895022572657153, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2220.06212 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 13, "params": { "seed": 13, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.07745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 225, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13326951501609982, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.28877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 365.9, "materialRemaining": 434.1, "materialInTransit": 45.9, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4011.12436, "distance": 10002.738, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7493, "staleVisits": 171, "workPerEnergy": 0.07977812986628685, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2480.67241 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 345.2, "materialRemaining": 454.8, "materialInTransit": 25.2, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3608.08739, "distance": 7497.853, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5463, "staleVisits": 123, "workPerEnergy": 0.08868964788316823, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2231.43194 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 14, "params": { "seed": 14, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.60245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 246, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13323844092689308, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.38877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 375.8, "materialRemaining": 424.2, "materialInTransit": 55.8, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4001.59374, "distance": 9974.64, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7522, "staleVisits": 172, "workPerEnergy": 0.07996813784408964, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2470.46679 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 354.2, "materialRemaining": 445.8, "materialInTransit": 34.2, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3600.00572, "distance": 7478.797, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5486, "staleVisits": 122, "workPerEnergy": 0.08888874761382438, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2222.50027 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 15, "params": { "seed": 15, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.47745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 241, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13324583820511907, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.26377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 361.85, "materialRemaining": 438.15, "materialInTransit": 41.85, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4014.69484, "distance": 10014.232, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7468, "staleVisits": 171, "workPerEnergy": 0.07970717897802668, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2484.04289 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 340.25, "materialRemaining": 459.75, "materialInTransit": 20.25, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3612.09279, "distance": 7514.49, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5403, "staleVisits": 123, "workPerEnergy": 0.08859130107576924, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2235.28734 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 16, "params": { "seed": 16, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.25245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 232, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13325915537601168, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.38877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 370.4, "materialRemaining": 429.6, "materialInTransit": 50.4, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4008.56272, "distance": 9989.966, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7577, "staleVisits": 171, "workPerEnergy": 0.07982911151722036, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2477.76077 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 357.8, "materialRemaining": 442.2, "materialInTransit": 37.8, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3599.53137, "distance": 7471.151, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5590, "staleVisits": 121, "workPerEnergy": 0.08890046154169988, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2222.05092 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 17, "params": { "seed": 17, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.40245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 238, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13325027696633043, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.28877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 365.45, "materialRemaining": 434.55, "materialInTransit": 45.45, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4010.39052, "distance": 10004.015, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7445, "staleVisits": 172, "workPerEnergy": 0.07979272795435893, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2480.26357 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 342.95, "materialRemaining": 457.05, "materialInTransit": 22.95, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3607.82445, "distance": 7500.373, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5393, "staleVisits": 122, "workPerEnergy": 0.08869611156796052, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2231.544 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 18, "params": { "seed": 18, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.42745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 239, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13324879734640122, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.38877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 375.35, "materialRemaining": 424.65, "materialInTransit": 55.35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4005.00991, "distance": 9975.918, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7640, "staleVisits": 171, "workPerEnergy": 0.07989992720049072, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2474.55796 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 349.7, "materialRemaining": 450.3, "materialInTransit": 29.7, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3606.77338, "distance": 7485.098, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5608, "staleVisits": 123, "workPerEnergy": 0.08872195907156008, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2229.36793 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 19, "params": { "seed": 19, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.45245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 240, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13324731775933096, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.23877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 373.55, "materialRemaining": 426.45, "materialInTransit": 53.55, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4005.22456, "distance": 9981.026, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7574, "staleVisits": 170, "workPerEnergy": 0.07989564501424262, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2475.34761 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 350.6, "materialRemaining": 449.4, "materialInTransit": 30.6, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3602.07962, "distance": 7481.233, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5454, "staleVisits": 121, "workPerEnergy": 0.08883756993404705, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2224.92417 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 20, "params": { "seed": 20, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.60245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 246, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13323844092689321, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.43877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 378.95, "materialRemaining": 421.05, "materialInTransit": 58.95, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4000.78059, "distance": 9965.7, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7620, "staleVisits": 170, "workPerEnergy": 0.07998439120712585, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.5, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2470.05364 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 356.9, "materialRemaining": 443.1, "materialInTransit": 36.9, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3598.84494, "distance": 7469.84, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5559, "staleVisits": 123, "workPerEnergy": 0.08891741809450933, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2221.71449 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 21, "params": { "seed": 21, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.55245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 244, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.1332413997396212, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.31377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 373.1, "materialRemaining": 426.9, "materialInTransit": 53.1, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4008.36573, "distance": 9982.303, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7681, "staleVisits": 169, "workPerEnergy": 0.07983303462124203, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2477.33878 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 347.45, "materialRemaining": 452.55, "materialInTransit": 27.45, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3608.19017, "distance": 7487.585, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5583, "staleVisits": 121, "workPerEnergy": 0.08868712140448888, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2230.28472 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 22, "params": { "seed": 22, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.67745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 249, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13323400295418525, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.43877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 373.1, "materialRemaining": 426.9, "materialInTransit": 53.1, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4006.71573, "distance": 9982.303, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7615, "staleVisits": 172, "workPerEnergy": 0.07986591055156557, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.5, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2476.11378 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 357.35, "materialRemaining": 442.65, "materialInTransit": 37.35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3598.63893, "distance": 7476.31, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5513, "staleVisits": 122, "workPerEnergy": 0.08892250837685198, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2221.93348 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 23, "params": { "seed": 23, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.40245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 238, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.1332502769663305, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.21377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 374.95, "materialRemaining": 425.05, "materialInTransit": 54.95, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4004.82607, "distance": 9977.195, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7614, "staleVisits": 171, "workPerEnergy": 0.07990359488869023, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2474.29912 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 355.1, "materialRemaining": 444.9, "materialInTransit": 35.1, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3599.48437, "distance": 7472.343, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5514, "staleVisits": 121, "workPerEnergy": 0.08890162238741972, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2222.47892 } } ] }, { "regime": "calm-bulk", "seed": 24, "params": { "seed": 24, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "none", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.57745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 245, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13323992031683063, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.38877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 365.9, "materialRemaining": 434.1, "materialInTransit": 45.9, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4012.94936, "distance": 10002.738, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7566, "staleVisits": 172, "workPerEnergy": 0.0797418485494818, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2482.02241 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 344.75, "materialRemaining": 455.25, "materialInTransit": 24.75, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3609.25378, "distance": 7501.735, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5487, "staleVisits": 123, "workPerEnergy": 0.08866098629458785, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 0, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2230.79833 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 1, "params": { "seed": 1, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 600, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 815.23103, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 44, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.24532922745846672, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 340, "materialExtracted": 402.25, "materialRemaining": 397.75, "materialInTransit": 32.25, "cargoLost": 30, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2770.56528, "distance": 7080.59, "survivors": 14, "capacitySurviving": 70, "shockDeaths": 10, "messages": 2302, "staleVisits": 3, "workPerEnergy": 0.12271863900711226, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 0.6060606060606061, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1334.91388 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 350, "materialExtracted": 420.9, "materialRemaining": 379.1, "materialInTransit": 40.9, "cargoLost": 30, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2498.54348, "distance": 5386.01, "survivors": 11, "capacitySurviving": 70, "shockDeaths": 7, "messages": 1769, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14008161283200157, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 210, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.6086956521739131, "recoveryTicks": 173, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1217.78636 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 2, "params": { "seed": 2, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2185.9948, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 134, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13723728895656268, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1370.78877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 365, "materialExtracted": 431.35, "materialRemaining": 368.65, "materialInTransit": 46.35, "cargoLost": 20, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2959.36541, "distance": 7563.357, "survivors": 16, "capacitySurviving": 80, "shockDeaths": 8, "messages": 2452, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.12333725294778287, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 215, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.671875, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1523.96401 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 365, "materialExtracted": 431.35, "materialRemaining": 368.65, "materialInTransit": 41.35, "cargoLost": 25, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2596.27158, "distance": 5644.047, "survivors": 12, "capacitySurviving": 75, "shockDeaths": 6, "messages": 1768, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.14058621712234745, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 220, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.6470588235294118, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1316.31446 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 3, "params": { "seed": 3, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2185.9948, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 134, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1372372889565627, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1370.73877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 310, "materialExtracted": 377.25, "materialRemaining": 422.75, "materialInTransit": 27.25, "cargoLost": 40, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2579.01966, "distance": 6586.328, "survivors": 12, "capacitySurviving": 60, "shockDeaths": 12, "messages": 2210, "staleVisits": 3, "workPerEnergy": 0.12020071202188554, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 165, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.5076923076923077, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1142.44326 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 330, "materialExtracted": 397.25, "materialRemaining": 402.75, "materialInTransit": 22.25, "cargoLost": 45, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2375.72855, "distance": 4917.802, "survivors": 9, "capacitySurviving": 65, "shockDeaths": 9, "messages": 1646, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.13890475842960487, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 190, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.5507246376811594, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1094.24643 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 4, "params": { "seed": 4, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 600, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 815.13103, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 40, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.24535932436521565, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 280, "materialExtracted": 345, "materialRemaining": 455, "materialInTransit": 30, "cargoLost": 35, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2391.47385, "distance": 6113.778, "survivors": 10, "capacitySurviving": 50, "shockDeaths": 14, "messages": 1961, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.1170826100999719, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 130, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.40625, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 955.94745 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 305, "materialExtracted": 375, "materialRemaining": 425, "materialInTransit": 30, "cargoLost": 40, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2176.82839, "distance": 4410.718, "survivors": 7, "capacitySurviving": 55, "shockDeaths": 11, "messages": 1413, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14011210118180523, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 160, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.47058823529411764, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 896.49627 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 5, "params": { "seed": 5, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2185.8198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 127, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1372482763790252, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 113, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1370.68877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 275, "materialExtracted": 340, "materialRemaining": 460, "materialInTransit": 30, "cargoLost": 35, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2287.60933, "distance": 5845.574, "survivors": 9, "capacitySurviving": 45, "shockDeaths": 15, "messages": 1899, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.12021283377002907, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 125, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.390625, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 851.88293 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 250, "materialExtracted": 340, "materialRemaining": 460, "materialInTransit": 35, "cargoLost": 55, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2001.30383, "distance": 4418.056, "survivors": 7, "capacitySurviving": 40, "shockDeaths": 11, "messages": 1439, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.12491856397574366, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 105, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.3088235294117647, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 720.64671 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 6, "params": { "seed": 6, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 600, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 100, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 815.30603, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 47, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.12265332981174028, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 325, "materialExtracted": 387.25, "materialRemaining": 412.75, "materialInTransit": 32.25, "cargoLost": 30, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2677.42254, "distance": 6841.76, "survivors": 13, "capacitySurviving": 65, "shockDeaths": 11, "messages": 2240, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.12138539781375089, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 175, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.546875, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1241.72114 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 370.9, "materialRemaining": 429.1, "materialInTransit": 25.9, "cargoLost": 45, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2255.34253, "distance": 4899.719, "survivors": 9, "capacitySurviving": 55, "shockDeaths": 9, "messages": 1588, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.13301748917168907, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 155, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.45588235294117646, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 974.91041 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 7, "params": { "seed": 7, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2185.9198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 131, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13724199763648431, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 113, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1370.76377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 280, "materialExtracted": 330.45, "materialRemaining": 469.55, "materialInTransit": 15.45, "cargoLost": 35, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2187.90645, "distance": 5590.141, "survivors": 8, "capacitySurviving": 40, "shockDeaths": 16, "messages": 1817, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.12797622101252434, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 130, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.40625, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 752.53005 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 295, "materialExtracted": 370, "materialRemaining": 430, "materialInTransit": 30, "cargoLost": 45, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2008.32836, "distance": 4151.417, "survivors": 6, "capacitySurviving": 45, "shockDeaths": 12, "messages": 1353, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.14688833065784834, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 150, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.4411764705882353, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 728.02124 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 8, "params": { "seed": 8, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2186.1698, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 141, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13722630329315752, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1370.93877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 370, "materialExtracted": 436.35, "materialRemaining": 363.65, "materialInTransit": 41.35, "cargoLost": 25, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2954.57877, "distance": 7550.586, "survivors": 16, "capacitySurviving": 80, "shockDeaths": 8, "messages": 2447, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.1252293573495137, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 230, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 0.696969696969697, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1518.87737 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 375, "materialExtracted": 440.45, "materialRemaining": 359.55, "materialInTransit": 35.45, "cargoLost": 30, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2658.50916, "distance": 5649.735, "survivors": 12, "capacitySurviving": 80, "shockDeaths": 6, "messages": 1820, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.1410565007590492, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 230, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.6764705882352942, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1377.75204 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 9, "params": { "seed": 9, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 600, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 100, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 815.25603, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 45, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.12266085219272024, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 270, "materialExtracted": 335, "materialRemaining": 465, "materialInTransit": 30, "cargoLost": 35, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2292.01214, "distance": 5859.622, "survivors": 9, "capacitySurviving": 45, "shockDeaths": 15, "messages": 1870, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.11780042331752753, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 130, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 0.3939393939393939, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 856.43574 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 305, "materialExtracted": 380, "materialRemaining": 420, "materialInTransit": 35, "cargoLost": 40, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2105.0383, "distance": 4391.337, "survivors": 7, "capacitySurviving": 50, "shockDeaths": 11, "messages": 1417, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.14489047568381436, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 165, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.4782608695652174, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 824.58118 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 10, "params": { "seed": 10, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2185.9948, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 134, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1372372889565627, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 115, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1370.71377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 270, "materialExtracted": 335, "materialRemaining": 465, "materialInTransit": 30, "cargoLost": 35, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2291.83714, "distance": 5859.622, "survivors": 9, "capacitySurviving": 45, "shockDeaths": 15, "messages": 1863, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.1178094183171053, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 120, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.375, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 856.16074 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 260, "materialExtracted": 340, "materialRemaining": 460, "materialInTransit": 25, "cargoLost": 55, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1964.72004, "distance": 4182.513, "survivors": 6, "capacitySurviving": 40, "shockDeaths": 12, "messages": 1339, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.13233437554012137, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 115, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.3382352941176471, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 684.26292 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 11, "params": { "seed": 11, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 600, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 100, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 815.23103, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 44, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.12266461372923324, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 265, "materialExtracted": 329.95, "materialRemaining": 470.05, "materialInTransit": 19.95, "cargoLost": 45, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2299.53995, "distance": 5873.671, "survivors": 9, "capacitySurviving": 45, "shockDeaths": 15, "messages": 1966, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.11524044213879894, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 115, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.359375, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 863.38855 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 280, "materialExtracted": 355, "materialRemaining": 445, "materialInTransit": 15, "cargoLost": 60, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2166.68435, "distance": 4682.889, "survivors": 8, "capacitySurviving": 50, "shockDeaths": 10, "messages": 1577, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.12922971474362754, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 135, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.39705882352941174, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 885.70223 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 12, "params": { "seed": 12, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2186.0198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 135, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13723571946838886, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 115, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1370.78877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 255, "materialExtracted": 326.8, "materialRemaining": 473.2, "materialInTransit": 31.8, "cargoLost": 40, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2300.4781, "distance": 5882.611, "survivors": 9, "capacitySurviving": 45, "shockDeaths": 15, "messages": 1873, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.11084652380130898, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 110, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.3384615384615385, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 864.6267 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 325, "materialExtracted": 400.9, "materialRemaining": 399.1, "materialInTransit": 40.9, "cargoLost": 35, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2332.9303, "distance": 4664.293, "survivors": 8, "capacitySurviving": 65, "shockDeaths": 10, "messages": 1503, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.1393097771953194, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 180, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.5294117647058824, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1052.14818 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 13, "params": { "seed": 13, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2185.8698, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 129, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13724513693594426, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 113, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1370.63877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 325, "materialExtracted": 400.9, "materialRemaining": 399.1, "materialInTransit": 50.9, "cargoLost": 25, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2772.17993, "distance": 7085.698, "survivors": 14, "capacitySurviving": 70, "shockDeaths": 10, "messages": 2292, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.11723625729608271, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 175, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.546875, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1336.22853 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 355, "materialExtracted": 440, "materialRemaining": 360, "materialInTransit": 65, "cargoLost": 20, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2549.6218, "distance": 5370.053, "survivors": 11, "capacitySurviving": 75, "shockDeaths": 7, "messages": 1736, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.13923633691230525, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 210, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.6176470588235294, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1268.53968 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 14, "params": { "seed": 14, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 600, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 815.20603, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 43, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.24533675099291552, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 275, "materialExtracted": 336.8, "materialRemaining": 463.2, "materialInTransit": 16.8, "cargoLost": 45, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2182.20515, "distance": 5572.261, "survivors": 8, "capacitySurviving": 40, "shockDeaths": 16, "messages": 1850, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.12601931562699678, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 140, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 0.417910447761194, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 746.57875 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 260, "materialExtracted": 325, "materialRemaining": 475, "materialInTransit": 5, "cargoLost": 60, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1800.28775, "distance": 3903.445, "survivors": 5, "capacitySurviving": 30, "shockDeaths": 13, "messages": 1322, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.14442135710086915, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 120, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.34782608695652173, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 519.63063 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 15, "params": { "seed": 15, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2186.0448, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 136, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13723415001611255, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 113, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1370.81377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 335, "materialExtracted": 392.7, "materialRemaining": 407.3, "materialInTransit": 22.7, "cargoLost": 35, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2673.10357, "distance": 6826.434, "survivors": 13, "capacitySurviving": 65, "shockDeaths": 11, "messages": 2291, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.1253224918800997, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 190, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.5846153846153846, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1236.82717 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 310, "materialExtracted": 401.8, "materialRemaining": 398.2, "materialInTransit": 36.8, "cargoLost": 55, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2447.02139, "distance": 5398.101, "survivors": 11, "capacitySurviving": 65, "shockDeaths": 7, "messages": 1818, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.12668463002340472, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 170, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.4927536231884058, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1166.08927 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 16, "params": { "seed": 16, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2186.0698, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 137, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13723258059973328, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 113, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1370.86377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 275, "materialExtracted": 350.45, "materialRemaining": 449.55, "materialInTransit": 25.45, "cargoLost": 50, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2496.6722, "distance": 6380.705, "survivors": 11, "capacitySurviving": 55, "shockDeaths": 13, "messages": 2095, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.11014661833411836, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 140, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 0.417910447761194, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1060.8708 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 290, "materialExtracted": 385.45, "materialRemaining": 414.55, "materialInTransit": 40.45, "cargoLost": 55, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2315.96705, "distance": 4918.534, "survivors": 9, "capacitySurviving": 60, "shockDeaths": 9, "messages": 1622, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.12521767091043712, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 155, "counterfactualPostWork": 350, "retention": 0.44285714285714284, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1035.48493 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 17, "params": { "seed": 17, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2186.1198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 139, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13722944187465955, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1370.81377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 325, "materialExtracted": 390.4, "materialRemaining": 409.6, "materialInTransit": 40.4, "cargoLost": 25, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2564.86706, "distance": 6550.567, "survivors": 12, "capacitySurviving": 60, "shockDeaths": 12, "messages": 2166, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.12671222021368558, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 180, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.5538461538461539, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1129.01566 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 375, "materialRemaining": 425, "materialInTransit": 35, "cargoLost": 40, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2038.88433, "distance": 4372.912, "survivors": 7, "capacitySurviving": 45, "shockDeaths": 11, "messages": 1417, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.14713929333906398, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 160, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.463768115942029, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 758.17721 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 18, "params": { "seed": 18, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2185.6948, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 122, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13725612561513473, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 114, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1370.58877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 315, "materialExtracted": 379.95, "materialRemaining": 420.05, "materialInTransit": 34.95, "cargoLost": 30, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2574.53884, "distance": 6579.942, "survivors": 12, "capacitySurviving": 60, "shockDeaths": 12, "messages": 2124, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.12235200913417331, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 170, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.5230769230769231, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1139.31244 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 335, "materialExtracted": 423.6, "materialRemaining": 376.4, "materialInTransit": 58.6, "cargoLost": 30, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2494.9689, "distance": 5375.758, "survivors": 11, "capacitySurviving": 70, "shockDeaths": 7, "messages": 1753, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.13427021096909547, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 195, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.5652173913043478, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1214.53678 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 19, "params": { "seed": 19, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2186.0698, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 137, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1372325805997331, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1370.86377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 355.9, "materialRemaining": 444.1, "materialInTransit": 10.9, "cargoLost": 45, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2380.89474, "distance": 6081.849, "survivors": 10, "capacitySurviving": 50, "shockDeaths": 14, "messages": 2004, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.12600305055094665, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 165, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 0.4925373134328358, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 945.36834 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 290, "materialExtracted": 358.6, "materialRemaining": 441.4, "materialInTransit": 13.6, "cargoLost": 55, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2091.03318, "distance": 4645.341, "survivors": 8, "capacitySurviving": 45, "shockDeaths": 10, "messages": 1499, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.13868742119868557, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 155, "counterfactualPostWork": 350, "retention": 0.44285714285714284, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 810.67606 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 20, "params": { "seed": 20, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2186.0948, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 138, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13723101121924913, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 114, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1370.83877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 360, "materialExtracted": 417.25, "materialRemaining": 382.75, "materialInTransit": 37.25, "cargoLost": 20, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2756.09802, "distance": 7039.721, "survivors": 14, "capacitySurviving": 70, "shockDeaths": 10, "messages": 2320, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.13061944743764567, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 220, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 0.6666666666666666, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1320.14662 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 385, "materialExtracted": 455.9, "materialRemaining": 344.1, "materialInTransit": 50.9, "cargoLost": 20, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2537.41561, "distance": 5347.352, "survivors": 11, "capacitySurviving": 75, "shockDeaths": 7, "messages": 1772, "staleVisits": 3, "workPerEnergy": 0.15172918428926227, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 240, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.7058823529411765, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1256.75849 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 21, "params": { "seed": 21, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 600, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 100, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 815.28103, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 46, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.12265709088689639, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 310, "materialExtracted": 390.9, "materialRemaining": 409.1, "materialInTransit": 45.9, "cargoLost": 35, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2892.60288, "distance": 7396.049, "survivors": 15, "capacitySurviving": 75, "shockDeaths": 9, "messages": 2401, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.10716991348905529, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 160, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.5, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1456.47648 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 335, "materialExtracted": 425.9, "materialRemaining": 374.1, "materialInTransit": 55.9, "cargoLost": 35, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2671.6604, "distance": 5669.864, "survivors": 12, "capacitySurviving": 80, "shockDeaths": 6, "messages": 1848, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.1253901881669231, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 190, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.5588235294117647, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1390.57828 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 22, "params": { "seed": 22, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 600, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 100, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 815.33103, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 48, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.12264956896723209, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 280, "materialExtracted": 352.25, "materialRemaining": 447.75, "materialInTransit": 37.25, "cargoLost": 35, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2493.63254, "distance": 6375.596, "survivors": 11, "capacitySurviving": 55, "shockDeaths": 13, "messages": 2048, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.11228599047516646, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 130, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.40625, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1057.90614 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 260, "materialExtracted": 342.25, "materialRemaining": 457.75, "materialInTransit": 22.25, "cargoLost": 60, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2106.04694, "distance": 4673.201, "survivors": 8, "capacitySurviving": 45, "shockDeaths": 10, "messages": 1534, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.1234540386972197, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 115, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.3382352941176471, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 825.26482 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 23, "params": { "seed": 23, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 600, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 815.13103, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 40, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.24535932436521532, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 250, "materialExtracted": 327.25, "materialRemaining": 472.75, "materialInTransit": 22.25, "cargoLost": 55, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2300.58693, "distance": 5881.334, "survivors": 9, "capacitySurviving": 45, "shockDeaths": 15, "messages": 1896, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.10866792147048249, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 115, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 0.34328358208955223, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 864.61053 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 255, "materialExtracted": 342.25, "materialRemaining": 457.75, "materialInTransit": 22.25, "cargoLost": 65, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2068.953, "distance": 4429.91, "survivors": 7, "capacitySurviving": 45, "shockDeaths": 11, "messages": 1470, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.12325074556582491, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 115, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.3333333333333333, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 787.89588 } } ] }, { "regime": "independent", "seed": 24, "params": { "seed": 24, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2186.0198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 135, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1372357194683888, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1370.81377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 290, "materialExtracted": 356.35, "materialRemaining": 443.65, "materialInTransit": 31.35, "cargoLost": 35, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2489.51206, "distance": 6364.102, "survivors": 11, "capacitySurviving": 55, "shockDeaths": 13, "messages": 2051, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.11648869037614587, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 145, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.4461538461538462, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1053.81066 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 295, "materialExtracted": 366.35, "materialRemaining": 433.65, "materialInTransit": 21.35, "cargoLost": 50, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2050.00161, "distance": 4404.925, "survivors": 7, "capacitySurviving": 45, "shockDeaths": 11, "messages": 1451, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.14390232612433218, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 150, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.4411764705882353, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 769.21949 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 1, "params": { "seed": 1, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.11368, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 47, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11388047096477213, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 310, "materialExtracted": 354.55, "materialRemaining": 445.45, "materialInTransit": 44.55, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3790.96882, "distance": 9470.161, "survivors": 22, "capacitySurviving": 110, "shockDeaths": 2, "messages": 6816, "staleVisits": 157, "workPerEnergy": 0.08177329201768833, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 190, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.95, "recoveryTicks": 53, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2262.11687 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 255, "materialExtracted": 336.95, "materialRemaining": 463.05, "materialInTransit": 81.95, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3316.65791, "distance": 6947.172, "survivors": 16, "capacitySurviving": 105, "shockDeaths": 2, "messages": 4792, "staleVisits": 107, "workPerEnergy": 0.07688462503617496, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 135, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.675, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1939.97746 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 2, "params": { "seed": 2, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.21368, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 51, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11386750367982569, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 361.85, "materialRemaining": 438.15, "materialInTransit": 41.85, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4016.49484, "distance": 10014.232, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7540, "staleVisits": 174, "workPerEnergy": 0.07967145805021639, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 54, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2485.61789 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 347.45, "materialRemaining": 452.55, "materialInTransit": 27.45, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3605.58439, "distance": 7496.66, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5437, "staleVisits": 121, "workPerEnergy": 0.08875121628391146, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 169, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2228.62894 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 3, "params": { "seed": 3, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.08868, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 46, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11388371324749752, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1531.67695, "distance": 3923.444, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 24, "messages": 1316, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.07834550230980022, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.5, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1377.73045, "distance": 2929.573, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 958, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.08709976614243656, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.375, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 4, "params": { "seed": 4, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.16368, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 49, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.1138739869531398, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1529.55195, "distance": 3923.444, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 24, "messages": 1231, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.07845434738200695, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.25, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1376.98045, "distance": 2929.573, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 928, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.08714720677574993, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.375, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 5, "params": { "seed": 5, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.06368, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 45, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11388695571484939, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1531.22695, "distance": 3923.444, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 24, "messages": 1298, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.07836852664074379, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1377.43045, "distance": 2929.573, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 946, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.08711873619630982, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.375, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 6, "params": { "seed": 6, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.13868, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 48, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11387722886665891, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 230, "materialExtracted": 257.6, "materialRemaining": 542.4, "materialInTransit": 27.6, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2853.92206, "distance": 7203.197, "survivors": 13, "capacitySurviving": 65, "shockDeaths": 11, "messages": 4023, "staleVisits": 75, "workPerEnergy": 0.08059084848175099, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 110, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.55, "recoveryTicks": 162, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1323.32011 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 230, "materialExtracted": 260.8, "materialRemaining": 539.2, "materialInTransit": 30.8, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2745.04264, "distance": 5725.727, "survivors": 11, "capacitySurviving": 75, "shockDeaths": 7, "messages": 3067, "staleVisits": 57, "workPerEnergy": 0.08378740506159103, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 110, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.55, "recoveryTicks": 161, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1367.66219 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 7, "params": { "seed": 7, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.16368, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 49, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11387398695314005, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 373.55, "materialRemaining": 426.45, "materialInTransit": 53.55, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4004.87456, "distance": 9981.026, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7560, "staleVisits": 172, "workPerEnergy": 0.07990262737419067, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 53, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2473.67261 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 352.85, "materialRemaining": 447.15, "materialInTransit": 32.85, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3603.37297, "distance": 7486.494, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5531, "staleVisits": 123, "workPerEnergy": 0.08880568353382468, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 58, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2225.96752 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 8, "params": { "seed": 8, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.13868, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 48, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11387722886665873, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1531.12695, "distance": 3923.444, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 24, "messages": 1294, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.07837364499664874, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1377.80545, "distance": 2929.573, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 961, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.08709502491974747, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 9, "params": { "seed": 9, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.03868, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 44, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11389019836684344, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 363.2, "materialRemaining": 436.8, "materialInTransit": 43.2, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4011.74634, "distance": 10010.401, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7406, "staleVisits": 171, "workPerEnergy": 0.0797657609640796, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 166, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2481.54439 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 342.05, "materialRemaining": 457.95, "materialInTransit": 22.05, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3608.89794, "distance": 7504.205, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5380, "staleVisits": 121, "workPerEnergy": 0.08866972826021094, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 171, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2231.99249 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 10, "params": { "seed": 10, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.11368, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 47, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11388047096477281, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1529.02695, "distance": 3923.444, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 24, "messages": 1210, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.07848128512328342, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.375, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1375.65545, "distance": 2929.573, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 875, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.0872311449806107, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 11, "params": { "seed": 11, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.06368, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 45, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11388695571484904, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 245, "materialExtracted": 290.3, "materialRemaining": 509.7, "materialInTransit": 45.3, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3055.65904, "distance": 7677.025, "survivors": 15, "capacitySurviving": 75, "shockDeaths": 9, "messages": 4821, "staleVisits": 82, "workPerEnergy": 0.0801791027587315, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 125, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.625, "recoveryTicks": 55, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1525.75709 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 190, "materialExtracted": 215, "materialRemaining": 585, "materialInTransit": 25, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2169.10838, "distance": 4918.115, "survivors": 8, "capacitySurviving": 40, "shockDeaths": 10, "messages": 2166, "staleVisits": 23, "workPerEnergy": 0.08759359469888854, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 70, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.35, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 792.20293 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 12, "params": { "seed": 12, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.16368, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 49, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11387398695314012, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 230, "materialRemaining": 570, "materialInTransit": 30, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2319.53762, "distance": 5871.117, "survivors": 8, "capacitySurviving": 40, "shockDeaths": 16, "messages": 2980, "staleVisits": 31, "workPerEnergy": 0.08622408129169173, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 80, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.4, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 788.16067 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 150, "materialExtracted": 170, "materialRemaining": 630, "materialInTransit": 20, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1775.95551, "distance": 3916.819, "survivors": 4, "capacitySurviving": 20, "shockDeaths": 14, "messages": 1766, "staleVisits": 16, "workPerEnergy": 0.08446157531442668, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 30, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.15, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 398.50006 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 13, "params": { "seed": 13, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 877.78868, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 34, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11392263504560304, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1530.45195, "distance": 3923.444, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 24, "messages": 1267, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.07840821139409973, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1376.65545, "distance": 2929.573, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 915, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.08716778043650325, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 14, "params": { "seed": 14, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.21368, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 51, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11386750367982572, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1531.12695, "distance": 3923.444, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 24, "messages": 1294, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.07837364499664869, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.375, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1377.50545, "distance": 2929.573, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 949, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.08711399290820541, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.375, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 15, "params": { "seed": 15, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.21368, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 51, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11386750367982554, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1530.65195, "distance": 3923.444, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 24, "messages": 1275, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.07839796632023961, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1376.80545, "distance": 2929.573, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 921, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.0871582836938331, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.625, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 16, "params": { "seed": 16, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 877.86368, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 37, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11391290210212347, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 240, "materialExtracted": 293.8, "materialRemaining": 506.2, "materialInTransit": 53.8, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2946.4374, "distance": 7384.555, "survivors": 14, "capacitySurviving": 70, "shockDeaths": 10, "messages": 4899, "staleVisits": 100, "workPerEnergy": 0.08145430147491219, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 120, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.6, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1415.63545 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 220, "materialExtracted": 255, "materialRemaining": 545, "materialInTransit": 35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2637.04406, "distance": 5456.195, "survivors": 10, "capacitySurviving": 70, "shockDeaths": 8, "messages": 2825, "staleVisits": 52, "workPerEnergy": 0.08342674401411497, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.5, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1259.56361 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 17, "params": { "seed": 17, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.11368, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 47, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11388047096477234, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 160, "materialExtracted": 190, "materialRemaining": 610, "materialInTransit": 30, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2130.25043, "distance": 5419.001, "survivors": 6, "capacitySurviving": 30, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 2363, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.07510854021209126, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 40, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.2, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 600.12348 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 160, "materialExtracted": 170, "materialRemaining": 630, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1765.25551, "distance": 3916.819, "survivors": 4, "capacitySurviving": 20, "shockDeaths": 14, "messages": 1338, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.09063843685016575, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 40, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.2, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 388.97506 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 18, "params": { "seed": 18, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.03868, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 44, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.1138901983668437, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 375.35, "materialRemaining": 424.65, "materialInTransit": 55.35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4005.00991, "distance": 9975.918, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7640, "staleVisits": 171, "workPerEnergy": 0.07989992720049072, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 52, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2474.55796 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 349.7, "materialRemaining": 450.3, "materialInTransit": 29.7, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3606.77338, "distance": 7485.098, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5608, "staleVisits": 123, "workPerEnergy": 0.08872195907156008, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 168, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2229.36793 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 19, "params": { "seed": 19, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.21368, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 51, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.1138675036798256, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 373.55, "materialRemaining": 426.45, "materialInTransit": 53.55, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4005.22456, "distance": 9981.026, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7574, "staleVisits": 170, "workPerEnergy": 0.07989564501424262, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 54, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2475.34761 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 350.6, "materialRemaining": 449.4, "materialInTransit": 30.6, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3602.07962, "distance": 7481.233, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5454, "staleVisits": 121, "workPerEnergy": 0.08883756993404705, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 169, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.375, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2224.92417 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 20, "params": { "seed": 20, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.16368, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 49, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11387398695314006, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 235, "materialExtracted": 288, "materialRemaining": 512, "materialInTransit": 53, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2946.68137, "distance": 7399.88, "survivors": 14, "capacitySurviving": 70, "shockDeaths": 10, "messages": 4685, "staleVisits": 99, "workPerEnergy": 0.07975073329866882, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 115, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.575, "recoveryTicks": 54, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.5, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1415.95442 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 250, "materialRemaining": 550, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2331.23782, "distance": 5134.5, "survivors": 9, "capacitySurviving": 50, "shockDeaths": 9, "messages": 2938, "staleVisits": 35, "workPerEnergy": 0.08579133307218134, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 80, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.4, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 954.10737 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 21, "params": { "seed": 21, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.23868, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 52, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11386426231999854, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1531.02695, "distance": 3923.444, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 24, "messages": 1290, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.07837876402117094, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.375, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1377.90545, "distance": 2929.573, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 965, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.08708870409236981, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 22, "params": { "seed": 22, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.23868, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 52, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11386426231999877, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1530.60195, "distance": 3923.444, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 24, "messages": 1273, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.0784005273376986, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.5, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1376.70545, "distance": 2929.573, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 917, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.0871646146256743, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 23, "params": { "seed": 23, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 100, "materialRemaining": 700, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 878.18868, "distance": 146.249, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 50, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.11387074522420101, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1530.52695, "distance": 3923.444, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 24, "messages": 1270, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.07840436917762919, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 120, "materialExtracted": 120, "materialRemaining": 680, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 1377.00545, "distance": 2929.573, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 929, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.08714562458871535, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } } ] }, { "regime": "correlated", "seed": 24, "params": { "seed": 24, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "nodes", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 1, "layout": "clustered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2251.57745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 245, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.13323992031683063, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 90, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1373.38877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 365.9, "materialRemaining": 434.1, "materialInTransit": 45.9, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 4012.94936, "distance": 10002.738, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 7566, "staleVisits": 172, "workPerEnergy": 0.0797418485494818, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 53, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2482.02241 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 320, "materialExtracted": 344.75, "materialRemaining": 455.25, "materialInTransit": 24.75, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3609.25378, "distance": 7501.735, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 5487, "staleVisits": 123, "workPerEnergy": 0.08866098629458785, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 120, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 172, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2230.79833 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 1, "params": { "seed": 1, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 60, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 815.23103, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 44, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.24532922745846672, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 167.5, "materialExtracted": 231, "materialRemaining": 38, "materialInTransit": 8.5, "cargoLost": 55, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 2059.15447, "distance": 5302.779, "survivors": 6, "capacitySurviving": 30, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 1216, "staleVisits": 14, "workPerEnergy": 0.0813440673603577, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 27.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 0.08333333333333333, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 623.50307 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 177, "materialExtracted": 250.5, "materialRemaining": 32, "materialInTransit": 8.5, "cargoLost": 65, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 1761.40497, "distance": 3781.521, "survivors": 5, "capacitySurviving": 35, "shockDeaths": 13, "messages": 973, "staleVisits": 12, "workPerEnergy": 0.10048796421102042, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 37, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.1072463768115942, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 480.64785 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 2, "params": { "seed": 2, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 60, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 100, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 815.20603, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 43, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.12266837549645787, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 197.5, "materialExtracted": 259.5, "materialRemaining": 9.5, "materialInTransit": 32, "cargoLost": 30, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 2350.99111, "distance": 6061.414, "survivors": 9, "capacitySurviving": 45, "shockDeaths": 15, "messages": 1283, "staleVisits": 23, "workPerEnergy": 0.08400712335430445, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 47.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.1484375, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 915.58971 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 187.5, "materialExtracted": 261, "materialRemaining": 21.5, "materialInTransit": 23.5, "cargoLost": 50, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 2023.90051, "distance": 4332.337, "survivors": 6, "capacitySurviving": 40, "shockDeaths": 12, "messages": 929, "staleVisits": 21, "workPerEnergy": 0.09264289357400038, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 42.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.125, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 743.94339 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 3, "params": { "seed": 3, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 210, "materialRemaining": 50, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2303.35433, "distance": 384.328, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 55, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08682988847083029, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.49999999999999994, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1488.0983 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 34, "cargoLost": 25, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3099.2626, "distance": 8015.473, "survivors": 16, "capacitySurviving": 80, "shockDeaths": 8, "messages": 1447, "staleVisits": 80, "workPerEnergy": 0.06775805323532202, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 65, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.2, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1662.6862 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 222.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 35, "cargoLost": 25, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 2890.51461, "distance": 6244.476, "survivors": 13, "capacitySurviving": 85, "shockDeaths": 5, "messages": 1106, "staleVisits": 63, "workPerEnergy": 0.07697591258284515, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 82.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.2391304347826087, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1609.03249 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 4, "params": { "seed": 4, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 210, "materialRemaining": 50, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2303.25433, "distance": 384.328, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 51, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.0868336583492654, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1488.1233 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 235, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 34, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3636.5669, "distance": 9424.183, "survivors": 21, "capacitySurviving": 105, "shockDeaths": 3, "messages": 1488, "staleVisits": 99, "workPerEnergy": 0.06462138785499315, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 85, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.265625, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2201.0405 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 247.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3278.58016, "distance": 7090.13, "survivors": 16, "capacitySurviving": 105, "shockDeaths": 2, "messages": 1125, "staleVisits": 86, "workPerEnergy": 0.07548999511163977, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 102.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.3014705882352941, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1998.24804 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 5, "params": { "seed": 5, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 210, "materialRemaining": 50, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2303.15433, "distance": 384.328, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 47, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08683742855506685, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1488.0233 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 220, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 34, "cargoLost": 15, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 2987.04979, "distance": 7721.725, "survivors": 15, "capacitySurviving": 75, "shockDeaths": 9, "messages": 1424, "staleVisits": 75, "workPerEnergy": 0.07365126643201368, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 70, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.21875, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1551.32339 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 232.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 35, "cargoLost": 15, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 2781.59018, "distance": 5962.274, "survivors": 12, "capacitySurviving": 80, "shockDeaths": 6, "messages": 1080, "staleVisits": 58, "workPerEnergy": 0.08358528201854738, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 87.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.25735294117647056, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1500.93306 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 6, "params": { "seed": 6, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 210, "materialRemaining": 50, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2303.30433, "distance": 384.328, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 53, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08683177336912958, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.49999999999999994, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1487.9983 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 205, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 34, "cargoLost": 30, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 2884.60246, "distance": 7439.473, "survivors": 15, "capacitySurviving": 75, "shockDeaths": 9, "messages": 1447, "staleVisits": 88, "workPerEnergy": 0.07106698496564895, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 55, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.171875, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1448.90106 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 217.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 35, "cargoLost": 30, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 2609.42577, "distance": 5652.977, "survivors": 12, "capacitySurviving": 80, "shockDeaths": 6, "messages": 1125, "staleVisits": 64, "workPerEnergy": 0.08335167150330518, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 72.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.21323529411764705, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1328.99365 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 7, "params": { "seed": 7, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 60, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 815.15603, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 41, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.2453517994462471, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 177.5, "materialExtracted": 231, "materialRemaining": 38, "materialInTransit": 8.5, "cargoLost": 45, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 1956.68214, "distance": 5020.526, "survivors": 6, "capacitySurviving": 30, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 1238, "staleVisits": 12, "workPerEnergy": 0.09071478495341927, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 27.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.0859375, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 521.30574 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 175, "materialExtracted": 243.5, "materialRemaining": 39, "materialInTransit": 8.5, "cargoLost": 60, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 1667.18244, "distance": 3520.98, "survivors": 5, "capacitySurviving": 35, "shockDeaths": 13, "messages": 1008, "staleVisits": 9, "workPerEnergy": 0.1049675161877362, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 30, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.08823529411764706, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 386.87532 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 8, "params": { "seed": 8, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 210, "materialRemaining": 50, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2303.22933, "distance": 384.328, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 50, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08683460087002345, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.49999999999999994, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1487.9983 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 235, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 34, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3315.32225, "distance": 8579.979, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 90, "shockDeaths": 6, "messages": 1494, "staleVisits": 107, "workPerEnergy": 0.07088300393467431, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 95, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 0.2878787878787879, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1879.62085 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 247.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3064.66663, "distance": 6529.472, "survivors": 14, "capacitySurviving": 95, "shockDeaths": 4, "messages": 1119, "staleVisits": 81, "workPerEnergy": 0.08075919172516419, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 102.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.3014705882352941, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1783.90951 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 9, "params": { "seed": 9, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 60, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 100, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 815.25603, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 45, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.12266085219272024, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 140, "materialExtracted": 210, "materialRemaining": 59, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 70, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 1435.5764, "distance": 3670.565, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 24, "messages": 1164, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.09752180350658636, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 140, "materialExtracted": 225, "materialRemaining": 57.5, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 85, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 1280.45712, "distance": 2719.959, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 876, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.10933595366933692, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 10, "params": { "seed": 10, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 210, "materialRemaining": 50, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2303.40433, "distance": 384.328, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 57, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08682800365436191, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1488.1233 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 205, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 34, "cargoLost": 30, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 2990.72027, "distance": 7733.22, "survivors": 15, "capacitySurviving": 75, "shockDeaths": 9, "messages": 1403, "staleVisits": 83, "workPerEnergy": 0.06854536080661759, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 55, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.171875, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1555.04387 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 217.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 35, "cargoLost": 30, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 2617.44433, "distance": 5678.554, "survivors": 12, "capacitySurviving": 80, "shockDeaths": 6, "messages": 1095, "staleVisits": 57, "workPerEnergy": 0.0830963232423928, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 72.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.21323529411764705, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1336.98721 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 11, "params": { "seed": 11, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 60, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 100, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 815.23103, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 44, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.12266461372923324, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 150, "materialExtracted": 210, "materialRemaining": 59, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 60, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 1436.1514, "distance": 3670.565, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 24, "messages": 1187, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.10444581230854684, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 145, "materialExtracted": 225, "materialRemaining": 57.5, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 80, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 1280.98212, "distance": 2719.959, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 897, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.11319439834192979, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 12, "params": { "seed": 12, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 210, "materialRemaining": 50, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2303.20433, "distance": 384.328, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 49, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08683554341124267, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1487.9733 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 205, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 34, "cargoLost": 30, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 2988.73061, "distance": 7728.111, "survivors": 15, "capacitySurviving": 75, "shockDeaths": 9, "messages": 1398, "staleVisits": 57, "workPerEnergy": 0.06859099281831985, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 60, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.18461538461538463, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1552.87921 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 217.5, "materialExtracted": 273.5, "materialRemaining": 9, "materialInTransit": 26, "cargoLost": 30, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 2783.70935, "distance": 5964.743, "survivors": 12, "capacitySurviving": 80, "shockDeaths": 6, "messages": 1072, "staleVisits": 51, "workPerEnergy": 0.0781331571943156, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 72.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.21323529411764705, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1502.92723 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 13, "params": { "seed": 13, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 60, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 815.23103, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 44, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.24532922745846736, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 150, "materialExtracted": 210, "materialRemaining": 59, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 60, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 1435.9514, "distance": 3670.565, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 24, "messages": 1179, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.10446035957135943, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 145, "materialExtracted": 225, "materialRemaining": 57.5, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 80, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 1281.08212, "distance": 2719.959, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 901, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.11318556249941382, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 14, "params": { "seed": 14, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 210, "materialRemaining": 50, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2303.15433, "distance": 384.328, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 47, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08683742855506682, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1487.9483 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 235, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 34, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3417.8691, "distance": 8850.737, "survivors": 19, "capacitySurviving": 95, "shockDeaths": 5, "messages": 1466, "staleVisits": 116, "workPerEnergy": 0.06875629037680667, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 0.29850746268656714, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1982.2427 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 247.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3170.36907, "distance": 6804.012, "survivors": 15, "capacitySurviving": 100, "shockDeaths": 3, "messages": 1128, "staleVisits": 81, "workPerEnergy": 0.07806662077775588, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 107.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.3115942028985507, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1889.71195 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 15, "params": { "seed": 15, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 210, "materialRemaining": 50, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2303.35433, "distance": 384.328, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 55, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08682988847083024, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1488.1233 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 235, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 34, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3315.57225, "distance": 8579.979, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 90, "shockDeaths": 6, "messages": 1504, "staleVisits": 92, "workPerEnergy": 0.07087765923105928, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 90, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.27692307692307694, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1879.29585 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 247.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3062.52848, "distance": 6520.532, "survivors": 14, "capacitySurviving": 95, "shockDeaths": 4, "messages": 1164, "staleVisits": 70, "workPerEnergy": 0.08081557497694077, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 107.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.3115942028985507, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1781.59636 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 16, "params": { "seed": 16, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 60, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 815.20603, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 43, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.24533675099291577, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 157.5, "materialExtracted": 231, "materialRemaining": 38, "materialInTransit": 8.5, "cargoLost": 65, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 1950.65482, "distance": 5017.972, "survivors": 5, "capacitySurviving": 25, "shockDeaths": 19, "messages": 1211, "staleVisits": 10, "workPerEnergy": 0.08074211730985077, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 22.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 0.06716417910447761, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 514.85342 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 160, "materialExtracted": 243.5, "materialRemaining": 39, "materialInTransit": 8.5, "cargoLost": 75, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 1661.21244, "distance": 3520.98, "survivors": 4, "capacitySurviving": 30, "shockDeaths": 14, "messages": 946, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.09631519480946524, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 25, "counterfactualPostWork": 350, "retention": 0.07142857142857142, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 380.73032 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 17, "params": { "seed": 17, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 60, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 100, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 815.30603, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 47, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.12265332981174082, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 145, "materialExtracted": 215, "materialRemaining": 54, "materialInTransit": 5, "cargoLost": 65, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 1538.21592, "distance": 3938.77, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 5, "shockDeaths": 23, "messages": 1177, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.09426504947180589, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 102.36452 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 140, "materialExtracted": 230, "materialRemaining": 52.5, "materialInTransit": 5, "cargoLost": 85, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 1383.07163, "distance": 2988.163, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 5, "shockDeaths": 17, "messages": 888, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.10122396878872814, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 102.36451 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 18, "params": { "seed": 18, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 60, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 815.10603, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 39, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.245366849745774, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 167.5, "materialExtracted": 231, "materialRemaining": 38, "materialInTransit": 8.5, "cargoLost": 55, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 1950.96214, "distance": 5020.526, "survivors": 5, "capacitySurviving": 25, "shockDeaths": 19, "messages": 1186, "staleVisits": 10, "workPerEnergy": 0.08585507434617881, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 22.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.06923076923076923, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 515.73574 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 162.5, "materialExtracted": 246.5, "materialRemaining": 36, "materialInTransit": 9, "cargoLost": 75, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 1648.37591, "distance": 3518.527, "survivors": 3, "capacitySurviving": 20, "shockDeaths": 15, "messages": 890, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.09858188218454422, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 22.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.06521739130434782, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 367.94379 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 19, "params": { "seed": 19, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 60, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 100, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 815.20603, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 43, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.12266837549645755, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 135, "materialExtracted": 218.5, "materialRemaining": 50.5, "materialInTransit": 8.5, "cargoLost": 75, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 1749.22126, "distance": 4493.058, "survivors": 3, "capacitySurviving": 15, "shockDeaths": 21, "messages": 1171, "staleVisits": 3, "workPerEnergy": 0.07717720058053361, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 313.69486 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 135, "materialExtracted": 234, "materialRemaining": 48.5, "materialInTransit": 9, "cargoLost": 90, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 1486.09348, "distance": 3258.922, "survivors": 2, "capacitySurviving": 10, "shockDeaths": 16, "messages": 879, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.09084219913939146, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 350, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 205.73636 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 20, "params": { "seed": 20, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 60, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 815.25603, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 45, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.24532170438544001, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 140, "materialExtracted": 210, "materialRemaining": 59, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 70, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 1435.9514, "distance": 3670.565, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 24, "messages": 1179, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.09749633559993538, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 145, "materialExtracted": 225, "materialRemaining": 57.5, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 80, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 1280.65712, "distance": 2719.959, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 884, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.11322312435998558, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 21, "params": { "seed": 21, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 60, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 100, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 815.28103, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 46, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.12265709088689639, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 150, "materialExtracted": 210, "materialRemaining": 59, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 60, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 1436.1264, "distance": 3670.565, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 24, "messages": 1186, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.10444763049481529, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 145, "materialExtracted": 225, "materialRemaining": 57.5, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 80, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 1281.08212, "distance": 2719.959, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 18, "messages": 901, "staleVisits": 0, "workPerEnergy": 0.1131855624994138, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 22, "params": { "seed": 22, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 210, "materialRemaining": 50, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2303.35433, "distance": 384.328, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 55, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08682988847083029, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.49999999999999994, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1488.0233 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 235, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 34, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3314.57225, "distance": 8579.979, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 90, "shockDeaths": 6, "messages": 1464, "staleVisits": 95, "workPerEnergy": 0.07089904288297963, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 85, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.265625, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1878.84585 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 247.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3063.07392, "distance": 6516.565, "survivors": 14, "capacitySurviving": 95, "shockDeaths": 4, "messages": 1153, "staleVisits": 63, "workPerEnergy": 0.08080118414540526, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 102.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.3014705882352941, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1782.2918 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 23, "params": { "seed": 23, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 210, "materialRemaining": 50, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2303.25433, "distance": 384.328, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 51, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08683365834926532, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1488.1233 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 235, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 34, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3315.34725, "distance": 8579.979, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 90, "shockDeaths": 6, "messages": 1495, "staleVisits": 105, "workPerEnergy": 0.07088246942804034, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 0.29850746268656714, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1879.37085 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 247.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3064.75716, "distance": 6529.54, "survivors": 14, "capacitySurviving": 95, "shockDeaths": 4, "messages": 1167, "staleVisits": 73, "workPerEnergy": 0.08075680610682195, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 107.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.3115942028985507, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1783.70004 } } ] }, { "regime": "compound", "seed": 24, "params": { "seed": 24, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "compound", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 1, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 100, "materialExtracted": 200, "materialRemaining": 60, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 100, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 815.20603, "distance": 134.912, "survivors": 0, "capacitySurviving": 0, "shockDeaths": 1, "messages": 43, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.12266837549645773, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": -7.105427357601002e-17, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 0 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 192.5, "materialExtracted": 245.85, "materialRemaining": 23.15, "materialInTransit": 18.35, "cargoLost": 35, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 2367.79803, "distance": 6107.392, "survivors": 9, "capacitySurviving": 45, "shockDeaths": 15, "messages": 1284, "staleVisits": 14, "workPerEnergy": 0.08129916401265995, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 47.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.14615384615384616, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 932.09663 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 205.5, "materialExtracted": 265, "materialRemaining": 17.5, "materialInTransit": 19.5, "cargoLost": 40, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 2137.41555, "distance": 4591.432, "survivors": 8, "capacitySurviving": 55, "shockDeaths": 10, "messages": 1043, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.09614414938135038, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 60.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.17794117647058824, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 856.63343 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 1, "params": { "seed": 1, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.9698, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 93, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13730166889499135, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 111, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.73877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 533.15, "materialRemaining": 266.85, "materialInTransit": 63.15, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3709.81703, "distance": 9534.019, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2284, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.1266908841193231, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 330, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2274.16563 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 543.45, "materialRemaining": 256.55, "materialInTransit": 58.45, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3336.64119, "distance": 7117.008, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1708, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14535575538380208, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 345, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2055.88407 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 2, "params": { "seed": 2, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.9198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 91, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13730481092493937, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.71377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 532.25, "materialRemaining": 267.75, "materialInTransit": 62.25, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3710.29936, "distance": 9536.574, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2266, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12667441465178314, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2274.89796 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 542.6, "materialRemaining": 257.4, "materialInTransit": 57.6, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3336.67092, "distance": 7116.974, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1687, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.145354460091771, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2056.7138 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 3, "params": { "seed": 3, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.9198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 91, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1373048109249394, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.66377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 534.95, "materialRemaining": 265.05, "materialInTransit": 64.95, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3709.17738, "distance": 9528.911, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2333, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12671273229865626, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 325, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2272.60098 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 537.2, "materialRemaining": 262.8, "materialInTransit": 52.2, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3342.57951, "distance": 7121.947, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1760, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.1450975207328045, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 345, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2061.09739 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 4, "params": { "seed": 4, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.8198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 87, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13731109541627096, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 112, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.68877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 532.25, "materialRemaining": 267.75, "materialInTransit": 62.25, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3710.99936, "distance": 9536.574, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2294, "staleVisits": 6, "workPerEnergy": 0.1266505202552659, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2275.47296 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 543, "materialRemaining": 257, "materialInTransit": 58, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3336.43235, "distance": 7118.285, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1681, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14536485356333195, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2056.10023 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 5, "params": { "seed": 5, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.8698, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 89, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13730795309869587, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 113, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.73877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 537.7, "materialRemaining": 262.3, "materialInTransit": 67.7, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3706.32155, "distance": 9522.525, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2312, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12681036791533054, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2270.59515 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 535.35, "materialRemaining": 264.65, "materialInTransit": 50.35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3343.50797, "distance": 7128.35, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1715, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14505722876349228, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2062.85085 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 6, "params": { "seed": 6, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2185.0198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 95, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1372985270088422, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.71377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 538.6, "materialRemaining": 261.4, "materialInTransit": 68.6, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3705.18923, "distance": 9519.97, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2304, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.12684912194805872, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2269.48783 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 543.9, "materialRemaining": 256.1, "materialInTransit": 58.9, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3335.90886, "distance": 7114.453, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1716, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14538766518776636, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2055.47674 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 7, "params": { "seed": 7, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.8198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 87, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1373110954162707, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 113, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.66377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 531.8, "materialRemaining": 268.2, "materialInTransit": 61.8, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3710.84053, "distance": 9537.851, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2269, "staleVisits": 6, "workPerEnergy": 0.126655941295275, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2275.46413 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 535.8, "materialRemaining": 264.2, "materialInTransit": 50.8, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3341.678, "distance": 7125.778, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1668, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.14513666466401487, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2061.37088 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 8, "params": { "seed": 8, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.9698, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 93, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13730166889499157, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.73877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 531.35, "materialRemaining": 268.65, "materialInTransit": 61.35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3711.78169, "distance": 9539.128, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2288, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12662382624398644, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 330, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2276.08029 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 542.55, "materialRemaining": 257.45, "materialInTransit": 57.55, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3337.81231, "distance": 7120.856, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1710, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14530475492974343, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2057.05519 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 9, "params": { "seed": 9, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.8698, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 89, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13730795309869592, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.61377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 533.6, "materialRemaining": 266.4, "materialInTransit": 63.6, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3709.45087, "distance": 9532.742, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2288, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12670338992937502, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 330, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2273.87447 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 543, "materialRemaining": 257, "materialInTransit": 58, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3336.26596, "distance": 7114.403, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1697, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14537210347473026, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 345, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2055.80884 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 10, "params": { "seed": 10, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.9198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 91, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1373048109249394, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 115, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.63877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 531.8, "materialRemaining": 268.2, "materialInTransit": 61.8, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3710.76553, "distance": 9537.851, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2266, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12665850119714075, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2275.08913 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 542.1, "materialRemaining": 257.9, "materialInTransit": 57.1, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3336.91468, "distance": 7120.839, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1663, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14534384204404396, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2056.45756 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 11, "params": { "seed": 11, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2185.0698, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 97, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13729538526648183, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.83877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 531.35, "materialRemaining": 268.65, "materialInTransit": 61.35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3712.68169, "distance": 9539.128, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2324, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.12659313106107567, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2276.53029 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 541.2, "materialRemaining": 258.8, "materialInTransit": 56.2, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3338.79441, "distance": 7120.805, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1716, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.14526201379017528, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2057.81229 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 12, "params": { "seed": 12, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.9448, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 92, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13730323989199014, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 115, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.71377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 536.3, "materialRemaining": 263.7, "materialInTransit": 66.3, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3707.02888, "distance": 9525.079, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2303, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12678617155188507, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 325, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2271.17748 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 544.8, "materialRemaining": 255.2, "materialInTransit": 59.8, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3334.45153, "distance": 7111.899, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1695, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14545120715909274, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2053.66941 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 13, "params": { "seed": 13, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.9198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 91, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1373048109249394, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 113, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.68877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 532.25, "materialRemaining": 267.75, "materialInTransit": 62.25, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3710.92436, "distance": 9536.574, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2291, "staleVisits": 6, "workPerEnergy": 0.12665307993799993, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2274.97296 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 543, "materialRemaining": 257, "materialInTransit": 58, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3336.65735, "distance": 7118.285, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1690, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14535505121067196, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2055.57523 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 14, "params": { "seed": 14, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.8948, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 90, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13730638199384093, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 113, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.68877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 533.6, "materialRemaining": 266.4, "materialInTransit": 63.6, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3709.67587, "distance": 9532.742, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2297, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12669570509012393, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 335, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 82, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2274.04947 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 544.4, "materialRemaining": 255.6, "materialInTransit": 59.4, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3335.34506, "distance": 7113.159, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1701, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.1454122411175233, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 345, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2054.68794 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 15, "params": { "seed": 15, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.8948, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 90, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13730638199384088, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 113, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.66377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 537.7, "materialRemaining": 262.3, "materialInTransit": 67.7, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3706.57155, "distance": 9522.525, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2322, "staleVisits": 6, "workPerEnergy": 0.12680181483831357, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 325, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2270.29515 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 544.4, "materialRemaining": 255.6, "materialInTransit": 59.4, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3335.83386, "distance": 7114.453, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1713, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14539093395814182, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 345, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2054.90174 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 16, "params": { "seed": 16, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.9198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 91, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1373048109249395, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 113, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.71377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 531.35, "materialRemaining": 268.65, "materialInTransit": 61.35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3711.60669, "distance": 9539.128, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2281, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12662979648044542, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 335, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2275.80529 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 536.25, "materialRemaining": 263.75, "materialInTransit": 51.25, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3342.11184, "distance": 7124.501, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1704, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.14511782464335768, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 350, "counterfactualPostWork": 350, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2061.62972 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 17, "params": { "seed": 17, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2185.0448, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 96, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13729695611968928, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.73877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 534.05, "materialRemaining": 265.95, "materialInTransit": 64.05, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3710.10087, "distance": 9532.742, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2314, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.1266811918257813, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 325, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2274.24947 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 536.25, "materialRemaining": 263.75, "materialInTransit": 51.25, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3342.88944, "distance": 7127.089, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1720, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.1450840685456813, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 345, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2062.18232 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 18, "params": { "seed": 18, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.6948, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 82, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13731895183947834, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 114, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.58877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 532.7, "materialRemaining": 267.3, "materialInTransit": 62.7, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3710.2832, "distance": 9535.296, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2284, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1266749665267227, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 325, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 83, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2275.0568 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 537.2, "materialRemaining": 262.8, "materialInTransit": 52.2, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3341.81831, "distance": 7123.241, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1722, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.14513057118066852, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 345, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2061.38619 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 19, "params": { "seed": 19, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2185.0698, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 97, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13729538526648183, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.86377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 531.8, "materialRemaining": 268.2, "materialInTransit": 61.8, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3711.26553, "distance": 9537.851, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2286, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12664143713903697, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 335, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 87, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2275.73913 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 543.45, "materialRemaining": 256.55, "materialInTransit": 58.45, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3336.40239, "distance": 7115.714, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1706, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.145366158983455, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 350, "counterfactualPostWork": 350, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2056.04527 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 20, "params": { "seed": 20, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.9698, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 93, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13730166889499143, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 114, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.71377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 534.05, "materialRemaining": 265.95, "materialInTransit": 64.05, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3709.95971, "distance": 9531.465, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2327, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12668601205895427, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 330, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 83, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2274.00831 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 543.9, "materialRemaining": 256.1, "materialInTransit": 58.9, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3336.30002, "distance": 7115.731, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1713, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14537061921638075, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2055.6429 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 21, "params": { "seed": 21, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2185.0448, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 96, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13729695611968934, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.76377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 531.8, "materialRemaining": 268.2, "materialInTransit": 61.8, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3711.59053, "distance": 9537.851, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2299, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.126630347966682, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2275.46413 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 536.7, "materialRemaining": 263.3, "materialInTransit": 51.7, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3342.57327, "distance": 7125.812, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1726, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.1450977916295593, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2061.49115 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 22, "params": { "seed": 22, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2185.0698, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 97, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1372953852664819, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.73877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 533.15, "materialRemaining": 266.85, "materialInTransit": 63.15, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3710.39203, "distance": 9534.019, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2307, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.1266712508143529, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2274.66563 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 537.6, "materialRemaining": 262.4, "materialInTransit": 52.6, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3341.38835, "distance": 7120.67, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1731, "staleVisits": 1, "workPerEnergy": 0.14514924623703973, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2060.60623 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 23, "params": { "seed": 23, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.8948, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 90, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13730638199384096, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 112, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.76377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 533.6, "materialRemaining": 266.4, "materialInTransit": 63.6, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3709.65087, "distance": 9532.742, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2296, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12669655891511675, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 335, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2273.67447 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 535.35, "materialRemaining": 264.65, "materialInTransit": 50.35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3343.58297, "distance": 7128.35, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1718, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.1450539749808689, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 345, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2062.52585 } } ] }, { "regime": "blackout", "seed": 24, "params": { "seed": 24, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "communications", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.9198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 91, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13730481092493949, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.71377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 532.7, "materialRemaining": 267.3, "materialInTransit": 62.7, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3710.0332, "distance": 9535.296, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2274, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12668350249929655, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 325, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2274.3318 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 538.5, "materialRemaining": 261.5, "materialInTransit": 53.5, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3340.15861, "distance": 7120.704, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1704, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14520268529161898, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2059.37649 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 1, "params": { "seed": 1, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.57357, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 115, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.09136100873972894, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 10, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 0.09999999999999974, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.34254 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3975.70121, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2123, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.06766102030683997, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 129, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 0.39090909090909093, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2540.04981 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3569.40246, "distance": 7643.11, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1568, "staleVisits": 20, "workPerEnergy": 0.07914489970855433, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 142.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.41304347826086957, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2288.64534 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 2, "params": { "seed": 2, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.57357, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 115, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.091361008739729, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 110, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.5499999999999999, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.36754 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3976.40121, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2151, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.06764910935727346, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 119, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.371875, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2540.99981 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3568.28867, "distance": 7641.816, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1531, "staleVisits": 21, "workPerEnergy": 0.07916960381792292, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 137.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.40441176470588236, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2288.33155 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 3, "params": { "seed": 3, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.77357, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 123, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.09135306006571083, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 110, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.5499999999999999, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.51754 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3977.72621, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2204, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.06762657510899504, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 124, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.38153846153846155, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2541.14981 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3571.47701, "distance": 7637.9, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1659, "staleVisits": 22, "workPerEnergy": 0.07909892725962585, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 142.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.41304347826086957, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2289.99489 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 4, "params": { "seed": 4, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.62357, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 117, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.09135902144154905, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 10, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 0.09999999999999974, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.49254 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3975.40121, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2111, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.0676661262835811, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 119, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.371875, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2539.87481 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3571.85743, "distance": 7645.682, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1640, "staleVisits": 18, "workPerEnergy": 0.07909050288079571, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 137.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.40441176470588236, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2291.52531 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 5, "params": { "seed": 5, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.49857, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 112, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.091363989849113, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 10, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 0.09999999999999974, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.36754 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3975.72621, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2124, "staleVisits": 25, "workPerEnergy": 0.06766059484356099, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 119, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.371875, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2539.99981 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3570.50224, "distance": 7640.505, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1616, "staleVisits": 18, "workPerEnergy": 0.07912052181361133, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 137.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.40441176470588236, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2289.84512 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 6, "params": { "seed": 6, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.79857, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 124, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.09135206657870776, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 110, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.5499999999999999, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.49254 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3976.02621, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2136, "staleVisits": 25, "workPerEnergy": 0.06765548970154132, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 119, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.371875, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2540.32481 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3572.46239, "distance": 7648.253, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1638, "staleVisits": 18, "workPerEnergy": 0.07907710967031659, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 137.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.40441176470588236, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2292.03027 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 7, "params": { "seed": 7, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.62357, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 117, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.09135902144154888, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 10, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 0.09999999999999974, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.46754 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3975.35121, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2109, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.06766697735462851, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 119, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.371875, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2539.97481 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3566.99964, "distance": 7637.917, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1491, "staleVisits": 18, "workPerEnergy": 0.07919821376093661, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 137.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.40441176470588236, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2286.69252 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 8, "params": { "seed": 8, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.74857, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 122, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.09135405357432318, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 110, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.5499999999999999, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.51754 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3976.60121, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2159, "staleVisits": 26, "workPerEnergy": 0.06764570699903528, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 129, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 0.39090909090909093, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2540.89981 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3572.32122, "distance": 7646.976, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1651, "staleVisits": 22, "workPerEnergy": 0.07908023449303025, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 137.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.40441176470588236, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2291.5641 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 9, "params": { "seed": 9, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.54857, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 114, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.09136200242124116, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 110, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.5499999999999999, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.29254 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3975.05121, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2097, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.06767208423052946, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 129, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 0.39090909090909093, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2539.47481 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3570.06777, "distance": 7640.573, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1643, "staleVisits": 17, "workPerEnergy": 0.07913015056251949, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 142.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.41304347826086957, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2289.61065 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 10, "params": { "seed": 10, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.69857, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 120, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.0913560406563785, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 10, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 0.09999999999999974, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.41754 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3975.87621, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2130, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.06765804217624893, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 119, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.371875, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2540.19981 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3569.80269, "distance": 7645.716, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1580, "staleVisits": 18, "workPerEnergy": 0.07913602638307655, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 137.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.40441176470588236, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2289.34557 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 11, "params": { "seed": 11, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.72357, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 121, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.09135504710454541, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 110, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.5499999999999999, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.49254 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3975.92621, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2132, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.06765719132994703, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 119, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.371875, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2539.77481 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3570.7225, "distance": 7640.539, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1647, "staleVisits": 22, "workPerEnergy": 0.07911564112483659, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 137.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.40441176470588236, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2289.74038 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 12, "params": { "seed": 12, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.64857, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 118, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.09135802782487962, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 10, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 0.09999999999999974, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.41754 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3975.47621, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2114, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.0676648497171501, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 124, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.38153846153846155, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2539.62481 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3570.86863, "distance": 7644.388, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1608, "staleVisits": 18, "workPerEnergy": 0.07911240357267248, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 137.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.40441176470588236, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2290.08651 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 13, "params": { "seed": 13, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.52357, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 113, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.0913629961243689, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 10, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 0.09999999999999974, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.29254 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3976.55121, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2157, "staleVisits": 25, "workPerEnergy": 0.06764655755650967, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 119, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.371875, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2540.59981 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3572.07122, "distance": 7646.976, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1641, "staleVisits": 18, "workPerEnergy": 0.07908576911353168, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 137.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.40441176470588236, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2290.9891 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 14, "params": { "seed": 14, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.69857, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 120, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.0913560406563785, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 10, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 0.09999999999999974, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.49254 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3978.37621, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2230, "staleVisits": 27, "workPerEnergy": 0.06761552605994829, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 134, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 0.4, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2542.74981 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3570.6251, "distance": 7643.127, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1628, "staleVisits": 17, "workPerEnergy": 0.07911779936177055, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 142.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.41304347826086957, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2289.96798 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 15, "params": { "seed": 15, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.74857, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 122, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.09135405357432311, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 10, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 0.09999999999999974, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.51754 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3977.52621, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2196, "staleVisits": 26, "workPerEnergy": 0.06762997554291375, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 124, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.38153846153846155, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2541.24981 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3570.23134, "distance": 7639.262, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1646, "staleVisits": 18, "workPerEnergy": 0.07912652523303262, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 142.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.41304347826086957, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2289.29922 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 16, "params": { "seed": 16, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.74857, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 122, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.09135405357432322, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 10, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 0.09999999999999974, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.54254 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3976.20121, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2143, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.06765251205778393, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 134, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 0.4, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2540.39981 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3566.45138, "distance": 7636.691, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1521, "staleVisits": 18, "workPerEnergy": 0.0792103887766408, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 147.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 350, "retention": 0.42142857142857143, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2285.96926 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 17, "params": { "seed": 17, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.69857, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 120, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.0913560406563786, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 110, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.5499999999999999, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.39254 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3975.47621, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2114, "staleVisits": 25, "workPerEnergy": 0.0676648497171501, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 124, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.38153846153846155, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2539.62481 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3571.44103, "distance": 7641.799, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1646, "staleVisits": 19, "workPerEnergy": 0.07909972400414884, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 142.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.41304347826086957, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2290.73391 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 18, "params": { "seed": 18, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.42357, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 109, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.0913669711530504, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 10, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 0.09999999999999974, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.31754 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3974.82621, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2088, "staleVisits": 25, "workPerEnergy": 0.06767591489334703, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 124, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.38153846153846155, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2539.59981 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3569.86344, "distance": 7639.211, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1598, "staleVisits": 20, "workPerEnergy": 0.0791346797763583, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 142.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.41304347826086957, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2289.43132 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 19, "params": { "seed": 19, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.59857, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 116, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.0913600150798318, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 110, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.5499999999999999, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.39254 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3974.90121, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2091, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.06767463795755556, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 134, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 0.4, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2539.37481 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3569.47532, "distance": 7645.732, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1578, "staleVisits": 19, "workPerEnergy": 0.07914328417560934, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 147.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 350, "retention": 0.42142857142857143, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2289.1182 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 20, "params": { "seed": 20, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.72357, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 121, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.09135504710454544, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 10, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 0.09999999999999974, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.46754 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3975.17621, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2102, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.06766995627189529, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 129, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 0.39090909090909093, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2539.22481 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3569.34513, "distance": 7640.556, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1603, "staleVisits": 18, "workPerEnergy": 0.0791461708878509, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 137.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.40441176470588236, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2288.68801 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 21, "params": { "seed": 21, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.79857, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 124, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.09135206657870797, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 110, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.5499999999999999, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.51754 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3977.17621, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2182, "staleVisits": 25, "workPerEnergy": 0.06763592712519652, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 119, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.371875, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2541.04981 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3571.08867, "distance": 7641.816, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1643, "staleVisits": 19, "workPerEnergy": 0.07910752894064607, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 137.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.40441176470588236, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2290.00655 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 22, "params": { "seed": 22, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.74857, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 122, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.09135405357432315, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 110, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.5499999999999999, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.41754 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3976.05121, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2137, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.06765506430781393, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 119, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.371875, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2540.32481 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3567.13111, "distance": 7636.657, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1526, "staleVisits": 18, "workPerEnergy": 0.0791952948626926, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 137.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.40441176470588236, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2286.34899 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 23, "params": { "seed": 23, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.44857, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 110, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.09136597736345313, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 10, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 0.09999999999999974, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.31754 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3975.25121, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2105, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.06766867956095099, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 134, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 0.4, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2539.27481 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3571.29987, "distance": 7640.522, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1659, "staleVisits": 19, "workPerEnergy": 0.07910285061441605, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 142.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.41304347826086957, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2290.24275 } } ] }, { "regime": "resource-loss", "seed": 24, "params": { "seed": 24, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "resources", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.9, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 210, "materialExtracted": 220, "materialRemaining": 40, "materialInTransit": 10, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 540, "energySpent": 2298.49857, "distance": 383.195, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 112, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.09136398984911305, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 110, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.5499999999999999, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1483.29254 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 269, "materialExtracted": 269, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 531, "energySpent": 3975.32621, "distance": 10273.496, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2108, "staleVisits": 25, "workPerEnergy": 0.06766740289818052, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 124, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.38153846153846155, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2539.62481 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 282.5, "materialExtracted": 282.5, "materialRemaining": 0, "materialInTransit": 0, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 517.5, "energySpent": 3570.17464, "distance": 7637.917, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1618, "staleVisits": 19, "workPerEnergy": 0.07912778182019867, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 137.5, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.40441176470588236, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2289.39252 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 1, "params": { "seed": 1, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.4698, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 73, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1373330956670408, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 111, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.23877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 465, "materialExtracted": 530.9, "materialRemaining": 269.1, "materialInTransit": 65.9, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3698.6082, "distance": 9535.296, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1817, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12572296794330093, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 325, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 0.9848484848484849, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2262.9568 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 537.6, "materialRemaining": 262.4, "materialInTransit": 52.6, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3329.07634, "distance": 7124.755, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1349, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.14568605546822314, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 345, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2048.31922 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 2, "params": { "seed": 2, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.3948, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 70, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13733781092372252, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.18877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 530, "materialRemaining": 270, "materialInTransit": 60, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3694.46272, "distance": 9523.802, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1819, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.1272174158200789, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2259.06132 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 533.1, "materialRemaining": 266.9, "materialInTransit": 48.1, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3331.27264, "distance": 7124.603, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1337, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14559000493337942, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2051.31552 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 3, "params": { "seed": 3, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2178.41403, "distance": 361.654, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 82, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13771486742425104, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1363.158 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 532.7, "materialRemaining": 267.3, "materialInTransit": 62.7, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3699.9332, "distance": 9535.296, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1870, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.1270293204658741, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 325, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2263.3568 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 531.35, "materialRemaining": 268.65, "materialInTransit": 46.35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3339.22585, "distance": 7137.256, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1391, "staleVisits": 6, "workPerEnergy": 0.14524324548274287, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 345, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2057.74373 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 4, "params": { "seed": 4, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.2948, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 66, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13734409843633028, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 112, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.16377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 530, "materialRemaining": 270, "materialInTransit": 60, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3698.79936, "distance": 9536.574, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1806, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12706826022855183, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2263.27296 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 529.05, "materialRemaining": 270.95, "materialInTransit": 44.05, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3340.1431, "distance": 7144.953, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1338, "staleVisits": 6, "workPerEnergy": 0.1452033595463006, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2059.81098 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 5, "params": { "seed": 5, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.3448, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 68, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13734095460806522, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 115, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.21377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 531.8, "materialRemaining": 268.2, "materialInTransit": 61.8, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3692.86423, "distance": 9519.97, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1811, "staleVisits": 6, "workPerEnergy": 0.12727248314745132, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2257.13783 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 526.35, "materialRemaining": 273.65, "materialInTransit": 41.35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3337.00541, "distance": 7141.223, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1335, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.1453398902622678, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2056.34829 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 6, "params": { "seed": 6, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.5448, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 76, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13732838073412856, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.23877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 530.9, "materialRemaining": 269.1, "materialInTransit": 60.9, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3700.46553, "distance": 9537.851, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1854, "staleVisits": 6, "workPerEnergy": 0.12701104672219968, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2264.76413 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 533.55, "materialRemaining": 266.45, "materialInTransit": 48.55, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3329.61468, "distance": 7120.839, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1371, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.14566250055238697, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2049.18256 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 7, "params": { "seed": 7, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.2698, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 65, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13734567040443635, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 113, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.11377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 530.9, "materialRemaining": 269.1, "materialInTransit": 60.9, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3700.30669, "distance": 9539.128, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1829, "staleVisits": 6, "workPerEnergy": 0.12701649867013126, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2264.93029 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 534, "materialRemaining": 266, "materialInTransit": 49, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3333.49827, "distance": 7125.812, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1363, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14549280082168908, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2053.19115 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 8, "params": { "seed": 8, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.6198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 79, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13732366612495234, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.38877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 530, "materialRemaining": 270, "materialInTransit": 60, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3697.28471, "distance": 9531.465, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1820, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12712031596863888, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 330, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2261.58331 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 528.15, "materialRemaining": 271.85, "materialInTransit": 43.15, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3340.32457, "distance": 7143.693, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1375, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.1451954711281888, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2059.56745 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 9, "params": { "seed": 9, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.4448, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 72, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1373346673832922, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.18877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 531.8, "materialRemaining": 268.2, "materialInTransit": 61.8, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3698.72436, "distance": 9536.574, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1803, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12707083682485418, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 330, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2263.14796 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 530.4, "materialRemaining": 269.6, "materialInTransit": 45.4, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3334.64699, "distance": 7132.249, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1349, "staleVisits": 7, "workPerEnergy": 0.14544268136897476, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 345, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2054.18987 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 10, "params": { "seed": 10, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.3948, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 70, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13733781092372255, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 114, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.11377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 530, "materialRemaining": 270, "materialInTransit": 60, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3701.38018, "distance": 9542.959, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1816, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12697966069888997, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2265.70378 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 538.05, "materialRemaining": 261.95, "materialInTransit": 53.05, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3332.2276, "distance": 7127.174, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1349, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14554828122060268, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2051.77048 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 11, "params": { "seed": 11, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.5448, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 76, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13732838073412856, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.31377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 530, "materialRemaining": 270, "materialInTransit": 60, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3698.9082, "distance": 9535.296, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1829, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1270645214080126, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2262.7568 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 529.05, "materialRemaining": 270.95, "materialInTransit": 44.05, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3340.45667, "distance": 7143.642, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1347, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.14518972927858104, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2059.47455 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 12, "params": { "seed": 12, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.3698, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 69, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13733938274790436, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 115, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.13877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 532.25, "materialRemaining": 267.75, "materialInTransit": 62.25, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3697.15087, "distance": 9532.742, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1796, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1271249176816777, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 325, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2261.29947 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 541.65, "materialRemaining": 258.35, "materialInTransit": 56.65, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3322.7662, "distance": 7108.152, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1339, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14596272222382398, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2041.98408 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 13, "params": { "seed": 13, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.3448, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 68, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13734095460806522, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 113, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.11377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 531.35, "materialRemaining": 268.65, "materialInTransit": 61.35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3697.8832, "distance": 9535.296, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1788, "staleVisits": 6, "workPerEnergy": 0.12709974186454012, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2261.9318 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 535.35, "materialRemaining": 264.65, "materialInTransit": 50.35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3334.02846, "distance": 7130.989, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1354, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.14546966399370237, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2052.94634 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 14, "params": { "seed": 14, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2159.32174, "distance": 358.253, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 72, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13893251499664735, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 116, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1344.11571 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 530.9, "materialRemaining": 269.1, "materialInTransit": 60.9, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3700.87286, "distance": 9540.405, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1833, "staleVisits": 6, "workPerEnergy": 0.12699706751998027, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 335, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 83, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2265.24646 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 534.9, "materialRemaining": 265.1, "materialInTransit": 49.9, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3336.83451, "distance": 7139.98, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1369, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.1453473339355224, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 345, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2056.17739 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 15, "params": { "seed": 15, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.3198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 67, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.1373425265042067, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 113, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.08877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 530, "materialRemaining": 270, "materialInTransit": 60, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3699.6832, "distance": 9535.296, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1860, "staleVisits": 6, "workPerEnergy": 0.12703790426302944, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 325, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2263.4068 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 529.05, "materialRemaining": 270.95, "materialInTransit": 44.05, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3340.49721, "distance": 7143.71, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1393, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.1451879675888681, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 345, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2059.56509 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 16, "params": { "seed": 16, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.6448, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 80, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13732209466049583, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 113, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.43877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 530, "materialRemaining": 270, "materialInTransit": 60, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3701.23169, "distance": 9539.128, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1866, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12698475511256632, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 335, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2265.43029 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 529.95, "materialRemaining": 270.05, "materialInTransit": 44.95, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3339.99934, "distance": 7141.087, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1366, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.14520960935327193, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 350, "counterfactualPostWork": 350, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2059.51722 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 17, "params": { "seed": 17, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.5698, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 77, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13732680916176768, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.26377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 530, "materialRemaining": 270, "materialInTransit": 60, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3697.05971, "distance": 9531.465, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1811, "staleVisits": 6, "workPerEnergy": 0.12712805240607045, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 325, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2261.20831 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 537.6, "materialRemaining": 262.4, "materialInTransit": 52.6, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3332.42501, "distance": 7124.586, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1372, "staleVisits": 3, "workPerEnergy": 0.1455396592858474, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 345, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2051.71789 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 18, "params": { "seed": 18, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.1948, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 62, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13735038652466566, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 114, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.08877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 532.25, "materialRemaining": 267.75, "materialInTransit": 62.25, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3696.71121, "distance": 9527.633, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1853, "staleVisits": 6, "workPerEnergy": 0.12714003691025036, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 325, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 84, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2261.48481 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 535.4, "materialRemaining": 264.6, "materialInTransit": 50.4, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3331.90602, "distance": 7118.115, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1389, "staleVisits": 3, "workPerEnergy": 0.14556232897766533, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 345, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2051.4739 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 19, "params": { "seed": 19, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.8948, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 90, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13730638199384085, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.68877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 530.9, "materialRemaining": 269.1, "materialInTransit": 60.9, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3700.50669, "distance": 9539.128, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1837, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12700963385353992, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 335, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 87, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2264.98029 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 533.55, "materialRemaining": 266.45, "materialInTransit": 48.55, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3334.68297, "distance": 7128.35, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1362, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.145441112346016, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 350, "counterfactualPostWork": 350, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2054.32585 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 20, "params": { "seed": 20, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.6198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 79, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13732366612495223, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 114, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.36377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 533.15, "materialRemaining": 266.85, "materialInTransit": 63.15, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3697.70971, "distance": 9531.465, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1837, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12710570526672108, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 330, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 84, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2261.75831 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 533.1, "materialRemaining": 266.9, "materialInTransit": 48.1, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3331.05647, "distance": 7123.326, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1347, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.1455994527983948, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2050.39935 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 21, "params": { "seed": 21, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.5698, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 77, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13732680916176773, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.28877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 530.9, "materialRemaining": 269.1, "materialInTransit": 60.9, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3699.94053, "distance": 9537.851, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1833, "staleVisits": 6, "workPerEnergy": 0.12702906884959206, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2263.81413 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 539.4, "materialRemaining": 260.6, "materialInTransit": 54.4, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3326.16943, "distance": 7111.95, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1397, "staleVisits": 2, "workPerEnergy": 0.14581337798268712, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2045.08731 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 22, "params": { "seed": 22, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.6198, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 79, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13732366612495228, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.28877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 531.8, "materialRemaining": 268.2, "materialInTransit": 61.8, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3699.64053, "distance": 9537.851, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1821, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.12703936950458058, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 320, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2263.91413 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 531.3, "materialRemaining": 268.7, "materialInTransit": 46.3, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3338.77585, "distance": 7137.256, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1373, "staleVisits": 9, "workPerEnergy": 0.1452628213582685, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2057.99373 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 23, "params": { "seed": 23, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.2448, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 64, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.137347242408527, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 112, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.11377 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 530.45, "materialRemaining": 269.55, "materialInTransit": 60.45, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3699.34936, "distance": 9536.574, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1828, "staleVisits": 6, "workPerEnergy": 0.12704936838129258, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 335, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2263.37296 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 528.6, "materialRemaining": 271.4, "materialInTransit": 43.6, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3340.26077, "distance": 7142.398, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1380, "staleVisits": 5, "workPerEnergy": 0.14519824429843564, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 345, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2059.20365 } } ] }, { "regime": "sensor-loss", "seed": 24, "params": { "seed": 24, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "sensors", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 300, "materialExtracted": 400, "materialRemaining": 400, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2184.3948, "distance": 362.788, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 70, "staleVisits": 4, "workPerEnergy": 0.13733781092372263, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 200, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1369.18877 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 470, "materialExtracted": 531.35, "materialRemaining": 268.65, "materialInTransit": 61.35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3697.17587, "distance": 9532.742, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1797, "staleVisits": 6, "workPerEnergy": 0.1271240580734108, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 325, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2261.47447 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 485, "materialExtracted": 534.05, "materialRemaining": 265.95, "materialInTransit": 49.05, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3333.31444, "distance": 7127.089, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 1337, "staleVisits": 9, "workPerEnergy": 0.14550082489531854, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 340, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 1, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2052.53232 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 1, "params": { "seed": 1, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.10245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 106, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896391711009817, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1432.87142 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3765.27032, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2768, "staleVisits": 32, "workPerEnergy": 0.1168574796764713, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 300, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 0.9090909090909091, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2329.61892 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 479.5, "materialRemaining": 320.5, "materialInTransit": 49.5, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3245.34333, "distance": 6966.848, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2324, "staleVisits": 20, "workPerEnergy": 0.1324975377009933, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.8405797101449275, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1964.58621 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 2, "params": { "seed": 2, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.10245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 106, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896391711009824, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.49999999999999994, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1432.89642 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3764.99532, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2757, "staleVisits": 30, "workPerEnergy": 0.11686601509396108, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.90625, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2329.59392 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 484.05, "materialRemaining": 315.95, "materialInTransit": 54.05, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3240.05646, "distance": 6951.471, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2303, "staleVisits": 12, "workPerEnergy": 0.13271373686949675, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 285, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.8382352941176471, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1960.09934 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 3, "params": { "seed": 3, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.07745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 105, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896490644341859, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.49999999999999994, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1432.82142 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3765.94532, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2795, "staleVisits": 32, "workPerEnergy": 0.11683653439127442, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 295, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.9076923076923077, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2329.36892 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 490.85, "materialRemaining": 309.15, "materialInTransit": 60.85, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3396.48616, "distance": 7225.058, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2184, "staleVisits": 18, "workPerEnergy": 0.12660142847608552, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.8405797101449275, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2115.00404 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 4, "params": { "seed": 4, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.05245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 104, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896589579874327, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1432.92142 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3765.39532, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2773, "staleVisits": 34, "workPerEnergy": 0.11685360035339498, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.90625, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2329.86892 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 484.5, "materialRemaining": 315.5, "materialInTransit": 54.5, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3239.56552, "distance": 6952.799, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2298, "staleVisits": 18, "workPerEnergy": 0.13273384881746697, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 285, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.8382352941176471, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1959.2334 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 5, "params": { "seed": 5, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2247.92745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 99, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08897084290545507, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1432.79642 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3765.91149, "distance": 9654.073, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2775, "staleVisits": 33, "workPerEnergy": 0.11683758413383251, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.90625, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2330.18509 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 475, "materialRemaining": 325, "materialInTransit": 45, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3248.66358, "distance": 6975.738, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2293, "staleVisits": 32, "workPerEnergy": 0.13236212044717224, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 285, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.8382352941176471, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1968.00646 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 6, "params": { "seed": 6, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.30245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 114, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08895600323559988, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.49999999999999994, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1432.99642 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 485, "materialRemaining": 315, "materialInTransit": 45, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3672.29197, "distance": 9385.868, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2946, "staleVisits": 36, "workPerEnergy": 0.11981618126441085, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.90625, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2236.59057 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 480, "materialRemaining": 320, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3243.86337, "distance": 6964.277, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2291, "staleVisits": 26, "workPerEnergy": 0.1325579876290991, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 285, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.8382352941176471, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1963.43125 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 7, "params": { "seed": 7, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.07745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 105, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896490644341855, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1432.92142 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 485, "materialRemaining": 315, "materialInTransit": 45, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3671.0258, "distance": 9384.591, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2914, "staleVisits": 33, "workPerEnergy": 0.11985750676524123, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.90625, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2235.6494 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 478.15, "materialRemaining": 321.85, "materialInTransit": 48.15, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3145.76431, "distance": 6683.25, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2436, "staleVisits": 18, "workPerEnergy": 0.13669174110915477, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 285, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.8382352941176471, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1865.45719 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 8, "params": { "seed": 8, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.02745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 103, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896688517607271, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.49999999999999994, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1432.79642 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3765.62032, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2782, "staleVisits": 38, "workPerEnergy": 0.11684661822088052, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 300, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 0.9090909090909091, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2329.91892 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 60, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3397.24609, "distance": 7230.201, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2162, "staleVisits": 32, "workPerEnergy": 0.12657310923294438, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 285, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.8382352941176471, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2116.48897 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 9, "params": { "seed": 9, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.07745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 105, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896490644341862, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.49999999999999994, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1432.82142 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3765.19532, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2765, "staleVisits": 33, "workPerEnergy": 0.11685980739395438, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 300, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 0.9090909090909091, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2329.61892 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 494.95, "materialRemaining": 305.05, "materialInTransit": 64.95, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3391.84328, "distance": 7216.152, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2151, "staleVisits": 14, "workPerEnergy": 0.12677472533432732, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.8405797101449275, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2111.38616 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 10, "params": { "seed": 10, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.10245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 106, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896391711009827, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1432.82142 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3764.77032, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2748, "staleVisits": 35, "workPerEnergy": 0.11687299954484522, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.90625, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2329.09392 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 484.5, "materialRemaining": 315.5, "materialInTransit": 54.5, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3239.16552, "distance": 6952.799, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2282, "staleVisits": 11, "workPerEnergy": 0.13275023993400464, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 285, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.8382352941176471, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1958.7084 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 11, "params": { "seed": 11, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.07745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 105, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896490644341855, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.49999999999999994, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1432.84642 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3766.64532, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2823, "staleVisits": 34, "workPerEnergy": 0.11681482128395837, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.90625, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2330.49392 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 480, "materialRemaining": 320, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3244.68577, "distance": 6961.689, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2339, "staleVisits": 22, "workPerEnergy": 0.13252438919994747, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 285, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.8382352941176471, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1963.70365 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 12, "params": { "seed": 12, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.12745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 107, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896292779878152, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1432.89642 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3764.97032, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2756, "staleVisits": 29, "workPerEnergy": 0.1168667911028346, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 295, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.9076923076923077, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2329.11892 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 493.6, "materialRemaining": 306.4, "materialInTransit": 63.6, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3391.88444, "distance": 7217.429, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2134, "staleVisits": 14, "workPerEnergy": 0.12677318677899138, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 285, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.8382352941176471, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2111.10232 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 13, "params": { "seed": 13, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.15245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 108, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896193850946739, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1432.92142 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3764.92032, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2754, "staleVisits": 36, "workPerEnergy": 0.11686834315149891, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.90625, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2328.96892 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 483.6, "materialRemaining": 316.4, "materialInTransit": 53.6, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3240.76401, "distance": 6956.631, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2290, "staleVisits": 20, "workPerEnergy": 0.13268476144076516, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 285, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.8382352941176471, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1959.68189 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 14, "params": { "seed": 14, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.02745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 103, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896688517607264, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1432.82142 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3765.54532, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2779, "staleVisits": 25, "workPerEnergy": 0.11684894550567458, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 305, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 0.9104477611940298, "recoveryTicks": 86, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2329.91892 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 493.6, "materialRemaining": 306.4, "materialInTransit": 63.6, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3393.47797, "distance": 7218.689, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2168, "staleVisits": 11, "workPerEnergy": 0.12671365581039937, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.8405797101449275, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2112.82085 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 15, "params": { "seed": 15, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2247.95245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 100, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.0889698534400983, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1432.72142 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3766.93649, "distance": 9654.073, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2816, "staleVisits": 35, "workPerEnergy": 0.11680579211286109, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 295, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.9076923076923077, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2330.66009 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 490.45, "materialRemaining": 309.55, "materialInTransit": 60.45, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3397.05492, "distance": 7228.924, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2173, "staleVisits": 20, "workPerEnergy": 0.12658023195231397, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.8405797101449275, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2116.1228 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 16, "params": { "seed": 16, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.07745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 105, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896490644341866, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1432.87142 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3765.22032, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2766, "staleVisits": 28, "workPerEnergy": 0.11685903147782307, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 305, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 0.9104477611940298, "recoveryTicks": 89, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2329.41892 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 480, "materialRemaining": 320, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3243.54461, "distance": 6960.412, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2312, "staleVisits": 19, "workPerEnergy": 0.1325710147684694, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 295, "counterfactualPostWork": 350, "retention": 0.8428571428571429, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1963.06249 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 17, "params": { "seed": 17, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.12745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 107, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896292779878155, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.49999999999999994, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1432.82142 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3766.28649, "distance": 9654.073, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2790, "staleVisits": 28, "workPerEnergy": 0.11682595089928655, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 295, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.9076923076923077, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2330.43509 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 485, "materialRemaining": 315, "materialInTransit": 55, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3400.32777, "distance": 7240.401, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2125, "staleVisits": 31, "workPerEnergy": 0.1264583973357133, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.8405797101449275, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2119.62065 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 18, "params": { "seed": 18, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2247.97745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 101, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896886399674943, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1432.87142 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3764.69532, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2745, "staleVisits": 29, "workPerEnergy": 0.11687532788066485, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 295, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.9076923076923077, "recoveryTicks": 87, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2329.46892 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 481.35, "materialRemaining": 318.65, "materialInTransit": 51.35, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3242.45108, "distance": 6959.151, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2298, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.13261572493982154, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.8405797101449275, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1962.01896 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 19, "params": { "seed": 19, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.02745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 103, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.0889668851760726, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.49999999999999994, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1432.82142 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3765.47032, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2776, "staleVisits": 29, "workPerEnergy": 0.11685127288317752, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 305, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 0.9104477611940298, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2329.94392 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 485, "materialRemaining": 315, "materialInTransit": 55, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3400.13378, "distance": 7233.931, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2155, "staleVisits": 27, "workPerEnergy": 0.1264656121590614, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 295, "counterfactualPostWork": 350, "retention": 0.8428571428571429, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.625, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2119.77666 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 20, "params": { "seed": 20, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.15245, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 108, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896193850946735, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1432.89642 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3765.69532, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2785, "staleVisits": 27, "workPerEnergy": 0.11684429102878988, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 300, "counterfactualPostWork": 330, "retention": 0.9090909090909091, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2329.74392 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 489.05, "materialRemaining": 310.95, "materialInTransit": 59.05, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3397.70105, "distance": 7232.772, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2154, "staleVisits": 14, "workPerEnergy": 0.12655616073126458, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 285, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.8382352941176471, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2117.04393 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 21, "params": { "seed": 21, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.17745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 109, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896094924215549, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.49999999999999994, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1432.89642 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3766.19532, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2805, "staleVisits": 34, "workPerEnergy": 0.11682877878352997, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.90625, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2330.06892 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 479.5, "materialRemaining": 320.5, "materialInTransit": 49.5, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3245.27953, "distance": 6965.554, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2329, "staleVisits": 22, "workPerEnergy": 0.13250014241192296, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 285, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.8382352941176471, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1964.19741 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 22, "params": { "seed": 22, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.17745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 109, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896094924215535, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.49999999999999994, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1432.84642 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3765.29532, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2769, "staleVisits": 32, "workPerEnergy": 0.11685670379125034, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 150, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 320, "retention": 0.90625, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.25, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2329.56892 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 60, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3396.41353, "distance": 7225.041, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2170, "staleVisits": 23, "workPerEnergy": 0.12660413587934344, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 285, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.8382352941176471, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2115.63141 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 23, "params": { "seed": 23, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.02745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 103, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896688517607271, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 200.00000000000003, "postShockWork": 0, "counterfactualPostWork": 100, "retention": -2.842170943040402e-16, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 2.5000000000000004, "zeroPostWork": 1, "energyAfterShock": 1432.89642 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3765.39532, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2773, "staleVisits": 27, "workPerEnergy": 0.11685360035339502, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 135, "postShockWork": 305, "counterfactualPostWork": 335, "retention": 0.9104477611940298, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2329.41892 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 480, "materialRemaining": 320, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3244.85216, "distance": 6965.571, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2323, "staleVisits": 24, "workPerEnergy": 0.13251759348984302, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 140, "postShockWork": 290, "counterfactualPostWork": 345, "retention": 0.8405797101449275, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.75, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1963.79504 } } ] }, { "regime": "rubble", "seed": 24, "params": { "seed": 24, "steps": 360, "shockTick": 140, "fault": "terrain", "loss": 0.5, "resourceLoss": 0.65, "correlation": 0, "layout": "scattered", "sensorNoise": 0.1 }, "arms": [ { "id": "concentrated", "label": "One large carrier", "summary": { "workDelivered": 200, "materialExtracted": 300, "materialRemaining": 500, "materialInTransit": 100, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 2248.02745, "distance": 374.125, "survivors": 1, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 103, "staleVisits": 8, "workPerEnergy": 0.08896688517607271, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 100.00000000000001, "postShockWork": 100, "counterfactualPostWork": 200, "retention": 0.49999999999999994, "recoveryTicks": null, "recoveryCensored": 1, "preShockRate": 0, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1432.82142 } }, { "id": "distributed", "label": "Twenty-four small carriers", "summary": { "workDelivered": 440, "materialExtracted": 490, "materialRemaining": 310, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3764.59532, "distance": 9652.795, "survivors": 24, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2741, "staleVisits": 35, "workPerEnergy": 0.11687843247273712, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 295, "counterfactualPostWork": 325, "retention": 0.9076923076923077, "recoveryTicks": 88, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 2.125, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 2328.89392 } }, { "id": "hybrid", "label": "Six medium + twelve small", "summary": { "workDelivered": 430, "materialExtracted": 480, "materialRemaining": 320, "materialInTransit": 50, "cargoLost": 0, "resourceDestroyed": 0, "energySpent": 3243.94073, "distance": 6964.26, "survivors": 18, "capacitySurviving": 120, "shockDeaths": 0, "messages": 2283, "staleVisits": 29, "workPerEnergy": 0.1325548261676995, "initialCapacity": 120, "initialEnergy": 18000, "preShockWork": 145, "postShockWork": 285, "counterfactualPostWork": 340, "retention": 0.8382352941176471, "recoveryTicks": 40, "recoveryCensored": 0, "preShockRate": 1.875, "zeroPostWork": 0, "energyAfterShock": 1963.15861 } } ] } ] }